NFL GAME DAY DISCUSSION Official SF/GB playoff game thread, open for bidness...

[Joker]

Karl never won a championship. Rodgers has. Pretty big difference.

Malone played 82 game seasons and then long playoff runs...Rodgers tremendous accomplishment is not comparable on any level. He underperformed in his Bowl win and has never played more than three games to reach the final while Malone had to run a 7 game series gamut, team after team every season. Just stop while you're behind

 

[palialka]

And the last thing. Debo was a rock solid star at Clemson and is turning out to be a rock solid star in the NFL. Did the Pats pass over him for you know who?

Right state, wrong school…he went to South Carolina, but you’re right, he’s pretty damn good.

 

[LightSkinSmurf]

Nope. Playoff choke artist with regular season Stats perfectly describes Aaron Rodgers


.

I mean, no argument there. Still, completely dismissing his championship season as if it didn't happen in order to make your comparison seem more accurate is pretty lame.

 

[Danlove1989]

I think it was just a shot at the nfl:
- Brady suspended 4 games for being “generally aware“ and “destroying” his cell phone.
- Antonio Brown suspended a few games for getting a forged vaccination card.
- QAaron receives no penalties for lying about his vaccination status and not following unvaccinated player protocols.

But Goodell treats everyone the same.

The NFL isn't a bastion of integrity for better or worse.

 

[RicoG]

Game winning drives are overrated. So what that Brady had 5 to Rodgers 1. So what that Brady had the 3rd highest passing yards all time. Who cares that Brady had more TDs. Points are overrated too.

Rodgers 4 interception and highest rating. That's MVP, case closed.

 

[LightSkinSmurf]

You need to be clutch to be one of the greatest quarterbacks in the game. If you aren't clutch, you can't make the throws in the big moments. You lose playoff games, you dont' win superbowls. The goal of the league is win the superbowl. It's not to be an efficient QB with a big arm who puts up good numbers.

He won a SB.

 

[DropKickFlutie]

I'm enjoying the 49ers Cinderella run but JimmyG basically got lucky, it wasn't like he was clutch today. 2 failed fourth quarter drives but then the Freak 49ers punt block for a 5 yard TD. Hey sometimes being lucky works too.

Robbie Gould is their Vinatieri. Kicking 45 yards in snow like that probably felt like kicking a bowling ball.

.

 

[FreeTedWilliams]

Sick watching Debo and Brown ball today, instead we have Harry.

 

[LightSkinSmurf]

Malone played 82 game seasons and then long playoff runs...Rodgers tremendous accomplishment is not comparable on any level. He underperformed in his Bowl win and has never played more than three games to reach the final while Malone had to run a 7 game series gamut, team after team every season. Just stop while you're behind

I'm responding to people that tell me playoff success is all that matters. While, completing dismissing the guy that won a championship and trying to make him look worse than the guy that didn't. I assure you, I'm not behind. By your own logic.

 

[tigerjohn]

He won a SB.

Not enough. Plenty of decent but not all time great quarterbacks have won superbowls. With his mediocre playoff record he needs to win more playoff games and more superbowls.

 

[PatsWSB47]

Last year it was their defensive coordinator who blew it in the NFCCG, this year it's their STs coordinator. At some point Matt Lafleur needs to take responsibility. Tonight was on him as much as it was on Rodgers.

So predictable.

 

[Joker]

The NFL isn't a bastion of integrity for better or worse.

please get it straight..it's INTEGRITA and don't argue or I'll fine you 1 BILLION dollars and take all your nose picks....

 

[LightSkinSmurf]

Not enough. Plenty of decent but not all time great quarterbacks have won superbowls. With his mediocre playoff record he needs to win more playoff games and more superbowls.

Not enough to be compared to certain all time greats I agree. Enough to be considered one of the all time greatest QBs to ever play, along with his other statistics? Um. Yeah. Obviously.

 

[FrodoBagginz]

Now Aaron can leave the Packers and start up his next career in the crime journalism business.

 

[RicoG]

Next week Jimmy G will meet his 'Daddy'.

Hopefully it's Brady, not Stafford the milkman.

 

[DropKickFlutie]

I mean, no argument there. Still, completely dismissing his championship season as if it didn't happen in order to make your comparison seem more accurate is pretty lame.

It's not going to be a perfect comparison. They also aren't the same height either if you hadn't noticed. You can let your autism slide on this one and agree Rodgers is a choke artist with empty regular season stats. It was real fun to see him choke again.

.

 

[Ross12]

This is pretty damn funny, not gonna lie…

 

[LightSkinSmurf]

It's not going to be a perfect comparison. They also aren't the same height either if you hadn't noticed. You can let your autism slide on this one and agree Rodgers is a choke artist with empty regular season stats. It was real fun to see him choke again.

.

If you're going to act like postseason success is all that matters and completely dismiss the fact that one guy got it done and one didn't, I would say it's far from just not being a perfect comparison. It's an irrelevant comparison by your own logic.

 

[SVN]

Sick watching Debo and Brown ball today, instead we have Harry.

Agrre but no way of saying they wouldve survived here in our scheme and brady wanting these guys to be perfect and learning on the fly.

 

[Hammer of Thor]

49ers pyrrhic victory? Kittle, Samuel, now Trent Williams?
Trent Williams on crutches, headed for X-rays after Saturday's win - ProFootballTalk