PatsFans.com Menu
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans

Good article on Refreeing in sunday's game

Status
Not open for further replies.
Imagine the reaction of Walt Coleman reffed a Pats/Colts game?
 
Nice find !

Edited excerpts:

By Steve Czaban
Special to OnMilwaukee.com

....
INDIANAPOLIS -- The NFL's version of a mid-season Super Bowl between the powerhouse Colts and Patriots turned into a fiasco for the ages on Sunday.

....the NFL's incomprehensible decision to send one of its youngest, greenest head referees to officiate the most important regular season game the league has seen in more than 20 years.

....

I mean, really.... A game this big, and Ed "Hercules" Hochuli isn't your FIRST choice? If not him, how about Pete Morelli, Walt Coleman or the take-no-guff Mike Carey? Hell, give me Larry Nemmers in a pinch.

I won't get too in-depth about the actual calls in this game, although there were plenty to make you raise an eyebrow in suspicion:

The first long pass interference on Reggie Wayne was marginal.

The sideline call that Patriots coach Bill Belichick successfully overturned should have never been called in the first place.

The missed pass interference on third down against Kevin Faulk got Tom Brady hopping mad.

The offensive pass interference against Randy Moss was a total joke.

All told, the refs were merely a drag on the Patriots, not fully conspired against them like a good old fashioned NBA screw job.

....
It would be like CBS telling Jim Nantz and Phil Simms to take a seat, so they could work Ian Eagle and Solomon Wilcots into a big game for a change.

....

So, why did the NFL assign a total greenhorn to such a huge game? I'm stumped. I am sure the league will spin some jive about random rotation of crews, express total confidence in all of their referees and point out that instant replay is always there in case something really egregious happens.

Maybe, just maybe, they wanted a "pure" referee and crew, one that hadn't been tainted by previous Colt-Patriot showdowns. If you recall, the Patriots manhandled Colt wide receivers in their first two AFC Championship beat downs. Then, when Peyton and Company whined loud enough, the league tweaked the rules and Manning ripped the league for a record breaking 49 touchdowns.

This time, the league got lucky, and the team that got hit with a franchise-record 10 penalties for 143 yards actually won the game. Next time, just send the A-team in the first place.
 
Imagine the reaction of Walt Coleman reffed a Pats/Colts game?

I thought his name was Parry, not Perry...........
good article nonetheless......
 
Glad that this is now getting reported in non-NE media too.

Hopefully the calls are more balanced for all our future games, especially if we play the Colts again.
 
I mean, really.... A game this big, and Ed "Hercules" Hochuli isn't your FIRST choice? If not him, how about Pete Morelli, Walt Coleman or the take-no-guff Mike Carey? Hell, give me Larry Nemmers in a pinch.
I have to admit I don't know any refs by name (except Hochuli) but I certainly know their faces... the one guy who I think is probably the best ref in the league is a black guy, kinda thin, with a thin mustache. Anyone know who I am talking about..?
 
I have to admit I don't know any refs by name (except Hochuli) but I certainly know their faces... the one guy who I think is probably the best ref in the league is a black guy, kinda thin, with a thin mustache. Anyone know who I am talking about..?

Mike Carey.

He's good but the way he announces penalties is kind of annoying...He always pauses after the penalty, as if saying

"False Start....................................................................Offense" is going to create some drama that the false start might have been on the defense.
 
I think Corrente is the best out there right now. I'll take his crew any day. I think he maybe got the superbowl last year, which tends to suggest the league likes him too.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
GEORGE: What Do The Patriots Really Have In Brown?
MORSE: Brown 1st Day, Open Patriots OTA Practice, Raymond Berry Passes Away
McDaniels Praises Rookie Caleb Lomu’s Versatility, ‘Awesome Kid’
Patriots Coach Expected to Miss Time Ahead of Training Camp
TRANSCRIPT: Josh McDaniels Press Conference 6/2
Vrabel Addresses Christian Gonzalez’s Contract Situation, Practice Status
TRANSCRIPT: A.J. Brown Press Conference 6/2
Vrabel Calls TE Hill’s Injury “Devastating” – Confirms Veteran Will Miss 2026
TRANSCRIPT: Mike Vrabel Press Conference 6/2
MORSE: AJ Brown Trade Reactions, Onwenu’s Restructure, and Hill on IR
Back
Top