Week 9 NFL Games

[PATSYLICIOUS]

What kinda math was that from pagano.? I dont get it.

Yep, made no sense. I'm glad he did it

 

[Ozymandias]

What a catch by Nuk.

 

[SVN]

that catch might do it for houston.

 

[patsinthesnow]

Luck > Wilson by a decent margin

Swap them on their respective teams, and you'd see there's a difference in their talent level.

In terms of raw talent, and that means not including their teams, and just the individual

Luck is an A - Wilson is a B at best.

I'll state my case, it's all I can do.

Wilson vs. Luck

TDs: Wilson
Yards: Luck
Y/A: Wilson
Comp pct: Wilson
QBR: Wilson
Wins: Wilson
PPG: Wilson
Playoff wins/stats: Wilson

Rice/Tate/marshawn/bad OL vs. Wayne/Hilton/bad OL
Marshawn before and after Wilson

I understand why people like Lucks potential, but Wilson is overlooked.

 

[PATSYLICIOUS]

Keenum's eye contact > Brady's body language

 

[Ozymandias]

Keenum might be in for Tony Romo-esque meteoric rise if he keeps this up.

 

[SVN]

big miss but still woudve been a 2 score game

 

[SVN]

I'll state my case, it's all I can do.

Wilson vs. Luck

TDs: Wilson
Yards: Luck
Y/A: Wilson
Comp pct: Wilson
QBR: Wilson
Wins: Wilson
PPG: Wilson
Playoff wins/stats: Wilson

Rice/Tate/marshawn/bad OL vs. Wayne/Hilton/bad OL
Marshawn before and after Wilson

I understand why people like Lucks potential, but Wilson is overlooked.

I think more people talk about RG3, wilson and everyone else but the first guy picked.

 

[SVN]

And how about that throw!

 

[robbomango]

The 2 point conversion would'v put them within a TD and field goal as oppose to 2 TD's I believe.

 

[SoCal Pmen]

Decent touchdown dance emulating his initials TY. I'll give it an A-

 

[PATSYLICIOUS]

F***, Indy's going to win this

 

[Deus Irae]

I'll state my case, it's all I can do.

Wilson vs. Luck

TDs: Wilson
Yards: Luck
Y/A: Wilson
Comp pct: Wilson
QBR: Wilson
Wins: Wilson
PPG: Wilson
Playoff wins/stats: Wilson

Rice/Tate/marshawn/bad OL vs. Wayne/Hilton/bad OL
Marshawn before and after Wilson

I understand why people like Lucks potential, but Wilson is overlooked.

It's because Luck is the better quarterback by a comfortable margin.

 

[SVN]

The 2 point conversion would'v put them within a TD and field goal as oppose to 2 TD's I believe.

An extra pt wuld also have the same effect with a 2pt conversion, its just when you want to go for 2. I thought it was too early.

 

[Ozymandias]

Wilson vs. Luck

TDs: Wilson
Y/A: Wilson
Comp pct: Wilson
QBR: Wilson
Wins: Wilson
PPG: Wilson
Playoff wins/stats: Wilson

All these things are a function of team football not solely a measure of how talented a QB is.

Wilson plays in one of the most QB-friendly environments there is. The Seahawks have a great rushing attack, and a great defense. His responsibilities as a QB aren't on the level of Luck. Luck has to do more with less because his team as a whole isn't as talented.

There's no question Luck is more talented than Wilson, and the only reason this debate is even happening is the team vs. team thing - which as I pointed out is easily reconcilable by swapping them on their team. Luck would still look good on the Seahawks if not better, Wilson would look much worse on the Colts as his responsibilities would go beyond his skill level. He'd actually have to carry the team, something I doubt he can do at this stage in his career.

 

[PatsBoy12]

I'm calling it, Luck will lead another 4th quarter winning drive.

Also, if this kid Keenum continues to play like this, the future is bright for Houston. Story might play out like one we're all extremely familiar with.

 

[ausbacker]

I know we all have our binkies but Luck is the best young Quarterback in the NFL by a country mile.

 

[PatsBoy12]

I know we all have our binkies but Luck is the best young Quarterback in the NFL by a country mile.

By a country mile, I don't know. But the kid is the real deal and I love watching him play. I hope he can have some kind of rivalry during his career like the Brady v. Manning rivalry. It's just one of those things that'll be good for his legacy, as I'm sure he'll be being talked about as one of the greatest before his career is over.

 

[patsinthesnow]

No point in arguing. The argument will speak for itself over time.

 

[PatsBoy12]

What the heck was that? That may have been the worst punt I've ever seen.