I like McCluster, I really do. However my one question is his experience with pro style blocking schemes and adapting to them. Here's my basic thesis:
Kevin Faulk's primary value is, in my mind, his blocking. When the Pats go gun, Faulk is their guy. Most people assume this is for the flat release, but not in my mind. Faulk is in there because of the abundance of zone blitzing. The best protection scheme against zone blitzes in the spread is have a back next to the qb taking what is called a dual read. In dual read protection, the back reads inside to out the linebackers on his side of the field. The idea is that if the D sends one, he will pick them up. If the D sends both. The most direct lane to the QB is blocked and the QB has an easy quick release to the hot. Wanna know why Welker lead the league in receptions? That's why.
While it sounds like such a simple concept academically, onfield execution is a bit harder. Defenses understand this protection, and consequently there is a lot of delay stuff, show-no-go, and delay drops. Again, this stuff is relatively elementary, but at NFL gamespeed, somone without veteran instincts could end 12's career. Hyperbolic? Maybe. Possible? Definately.
Again, I like McCluster, but I think that there is a lot more to the gun/3rd down back than most people assume. In my mind, it is the hardest spot to fill on the O, so I'm interested in seeing how this kid turns out.