MiChargers

But you see, the Chargers DID stop them. They recovered a fumble. Our ball....Game over. How many plays do they have to dominate? It's not a series of 6 downs, it's a series of 4 downs. I dont care who the team is, when you give them extra downs, chances are they will capitalize. Just saying SD should have stopped them, is blatantly simplistic and ignoring the facts and impact of that situation. It was a game deciding bad call.

WhiZa

He went for 2 because neither defense was not stopping anything so put it in the hands your offense to win.

__________________

To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.
- 4 years =
To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

spacecrime

Exactly right on both counts. Evelryone is crediting Shannahan with making a guysy call when he said it himself post-game: he didn't want the game decided by the coin flip. His defense was bad and by hte end of the game was imcompetent. He knew if they lost the coin toss they'd lose the game and took the best option he had.

patchick

Can't stand the Chargers, but totally agree with this.

spacecrime

Not true. Not any team. Last week the Pats stopped the Chiefs for 5 downs at the goal line due to a time out called. We stopped them, but the play didn't count, and they ran 4 more, all of which we stopped. All you have to do was to stop a 2-point conversion. Like it or not, you deserved to lose.
Charger fans are the new Raider fans.

It was the correct call of a bad rule.

You may not like it, but the rule is very clear. You sound like the whiny Raider fans in 2001. (And like in 2001, they will review this rule next March and make no changes.)

I'm hoping Tomlinson grows a pair by next week and doesn't take himself out of the game for an "injury" that any other running back in the league would play through, you might actually beat the Jets. I wouldn't mind seeing the Jets lose another.

I'm sure the Chargers will find a way to blow this one, too. though.

Scouse Patriot

Over here they switched over after our game so I caught the last 9 or so mins. I thought he'd play the percentages and just kick he extra point but all credit to him for making that call. It's one of them were if it comes off your cool and if it doesn't your a total idiot.

cartmen

it was a really bad call probably one of the worst Ive seen but lets stop calling things like that a travesty I mean its a mistake and Hoc's a good ref. If you make a mistake at work no matter how big it is, even if you get fired for that mistake you still get paid for the days work you put in and you wouldn't give it back.

__________________
Our reign of dominance will continue with a healthy Brady and reformed D! SB champs in 2010 again -
To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

BradyFTW!

100% the right call with Shanahan. You should prefer to rely on your offense to get 2 yards on a gassed D, versus taking your chances with a coin flip.

__________________

To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

pao

Sorry, you are wrong. It was not a simultaneous catch and it wasn't claimed as one at the time. Bailey clearly grabbed the ball after Chambers made the initial catch. Also if it was non-reviewable why did they review it?

pao

It was an incorrect call unable to be overturned due to a bad rule. He incorrectly ruled an incomplete pass (despite the fact that if it WAS a pass it went backward, and by rule, would be a lateral and a live ball) and blew the whistle. The bad rule is that once the whistle blew the play can not be overturned even though it was clear what the outcome should be.

Still a bad call. And if it happened to the Patriots imagine the outcry (justified).