Who are your top 5 players from parts I & II of the Dynasty ?

[Ice_Ice_Brady]

Malcolm Butler
Dante Hightower
Patrick Chung
Julian Edelman

 

[Ice_Ice_Brady]

Any list that doesn't have Vinatieri in it is invalid.

Sorry, but that's the facts.

Racist ****.

 

[Nikolai]

Players not named Brady or Wilfork.

Dynasty 1.0
Willie
Harrison
Bruschi
Faulk
Law

Dynasty 1.1
McCourty
Edelman
Hightower
Chung
Ninkovich

Hard to leave out Vrabel, Seymour, White, Gronk, and many more. We've been very lucky as a fanbase to enjoy this team these last 20 years.

 

[Ice_Ice_Brady]

Players not named Brady or Wilfork.

Dynasty 1.0
Willie
Harrison
Bruschi
Faulk
Law

Dynasty 1.1
McCourty
Edelman
Hightower
Chung
Ninkovich

Hard to leave out Vrabel, Seymour, White, Gronk, and many more. We've been very lucky as a fanbase to enjoy this team these last 20 years.

Dude...what? Ninkovich and Chung over Gronk? Lol.

 

[fnordcircle]

Racist ****.

Ray Lewis Was Nice To A Guy

 

[fnordcircle]

Dude...what? Ninkovich and Chung over Gronk? Lol.

Nink and Chung over White is debatable but over Gronkers is bonkers.

 

[Flash]

Feel bad for guys like Wilfork and Mankins whose primes were in-between the two dynasties. At least Wilfork still got two rings out of it. Mankins didn't even get one.

Wes Welker, though. Wasn't playing for the Patriots in 2004. Didn't win a SB in undefeated season. Left the Patriots for 5Head for two years. Patriots won one SB. Left 5Head the same year Denver wins a SB off a historic defense.

 

[Nikolai]

Dude...what? Ninkovich and Chung over Gronk? Lol.

Ehhhhhh...meant to switch Chung and Gronk around. Probably did a couple times. Was drunk. Sue me.

 

[FCB02062]

Feel bad for guys like Wilfork and Mankins whose primes were in-between the two dynasties. At least Wilfork still got two rings out of it. Mankins didn't even get one.

Wes Welker, though. Wasn't playing for the Patriots in 2004. Didn't win a SB in undefeated season. Left the Patriots for 5Head for two years. Patriots won one SB. Left 5Head the same year Denver wins a SB off a historic defense.

Mayo as well - 2008-2015. Played in 1 sb in 11 and got a ring in 14 but was on IR after game 5 or 6 and didn't sniff the playoffs...

 

[sb1]

1
Victor Green
Donald Hayes
Deltha O’Neal
Chad Jackson
Doug Gabriel

2
Tebow
Jordan Richards
Cyrus Jones
Pot roast
Newhouse

 

[The Brandon Five]

I
Brady
Brown
Bruschi
Law
Mcginest

II
Brady
Edelman
Gronk
Hightower
White

 

[DropKickFlutie]

For clarity pretty sure the OP is asking for peoples's favorites, not necessarily the top5 most talented people or top5 most productive. This may seem like an obvious clarification but seems weird people are criticizing others above for their picks.

 

[1960Pats]

Part 2 of the question involves years that Vinatieri wasn't on the team. He was playing for bitter rival, the Indy Colts.So it IS valid not to list him on list 2.

He's a ST player only and imho he shouldn't be on a list any more than Matthew Slater.

 

[Uptown]

I’ll just leave this here...

Dynasty #3

 

[scott99]

For clarity pretty sure the OP is asking for peoples's favorites, not necessarily the top5 most talented people or top5 most productive. This may seem like an obvious clarification but seems weird people are criticizing others above for their picks.

Correct, your top 5 favorites during Part I and Part II.

 

[1960Pats]

For clarity pretty sure the OP is asking for peoples's favorites, not necessarily the top5 most talented people or top5 most productive. This may seem like an obvious clarification but seems weird people are criticizing others above for their picks.

I saw it the other way and now I'm glad that I didn't post my top 5's yet. I would have been bullied and ridiculed by the mean people here if I had.

 

[Vatahala]

I loved Rodney Harrison #2 for the intensity, competitiveness and leadership he brought to the team.

Also proud of his media skills and I think he is an
underrated TV analyst.

 

[Vatahala]

#3 Willie
His smile just lit up the room.

Plus I love the mentoring he does with kids today.

 

[hornetfb85]

Mo Lewis...

 

[Uptown]

Mo Lewis...

LMAO!!!!