Which quarterbacks do you have ahead of Drew Brees all-time?

[john4psu]

Which quarterbacks do you have ahead of Drew Brees all-time?

 

[Boomer B]

Brady
Montana
Marino
P. Manning
S. Young

In the conversation with Brees is Mahomes, Favre, Rogers, Elway. I’m not ranking the ones before the 80’s as I never saw them play.

 

[Football2007]

Brady
Montana
Marino
P. Manning
S. Young

In the conversation with Brees is Mahomes, Favre, Rogers, Elway. I’m not ranking the ones before the 80’s as I never saw them play.

I don't see a case for him over any of these guys. He is closer to a top 15 QB than 5 imo.

Can't say with certainty I would take him over Starr, Unitas, or Staubach either.

 

[Nikolai]

Never saw anyone play before the late 80s, but here's who I'd put, in particular order, ahead of Brees (stats do the heavy lifting for QBs before my time):

Brady
Montana
Marino
Starr
Unitas
Staubach (this dude is criminally underrated)
Elway
Manning
Mahomes

When it comes to Tarkenton, Young, Rodgers and Favre, I think they're right there with Brees somewhere. Total tossup.

I've got Brees ahead of Moon, Warner, Kelly and those types. Don't think I forgot anyone?

 

[1960Pats]

Never saw anyone play before the late 80s, but here's who I'd put, in particular order, ahead of Brees (stats do the heavy lifting for QBs before my time):

Brady
Montana
Marino
Starr
Unitas
Staubach (this dude is criminally underrated)
Elway
Manning
Mahomes

When it comes to Tarkenton, Young, Rodgers and Favre, I think they're right there with Brees somewhere. Total tossup.

I've got Brees ahead of Moon, Warner, Kelly and those types. Don't think I forgot anyone?

That list is okay but I'd move Mahomes up a bit, ahead of Elway, Manning and Staubach