I think that maybe the way to go these days might be doing the opposite of the hot takes culture. Do something unique and different. Kinda hit a relaxing and informative format. Maybe include some teaching segments. Have Ted Johnson talk about the unseen things a linebacker has to do. Maybe have some days where you make it all fan call-ins talking about favorite memories of a specific team, season, etc.
Find little historical stories for each team to talk about. Maybe a segment about the development of the passing game from early days to now. Bring in Grogan, Drew, Tom (if you can) and have them talk about the transitions in how the QB position played. Maybe Eason, too.
Random aside...looking at the way they played... I sincerely think Eason would be more appreciated in the modern game. He was all about a controlled measured passing game which didn't suit the '80s. And I think Drew would have been way more at home in the more lax, gunslinging '80s. Imagine Drew with Fryar and Morgan!