Only if you look at the stats
Given the fact that Tampa's secondary was depleted and were playing Richard Sherman was raw and rusty... Mac wasn't that great. I remember thinking he should have attacked Sherman more in that game.
Meanwhile Brady was going up against a defense whose head coach has known him for 20 years, and several players on the defense who have played with Brady for almost 10 years.
Mac was still alright in that game. I was more impressed with his composure than anything, and I wish Belichick let him have the ball in crunch time.