Toughest QB?

[GoWhalers]

Does David Carr make the list? Obviously he's not a winning QB, but the number of hits he's taken in the last three years, and how he's carried himself in the media -- no complaining or throwing teammates under the bus -- should at least meet the criteria of "tough".

 

[Terry Glenn is a cowgirl]

Actually, Carr is probably one of the toughest imo also...good call.

His oline was so bad...

Drew is also pretty tough. Not mentally though...like someone else said before.

 

[JoeSixPat]

Any list like this with McNair and not Bledsoe is not a correct list.

Agree 100% - they both have their flaws as QBs - but if we're talking tough, these guys need to be on the list.... and I don't even count a tough Mo Lewis hit for Bledsoe...

He had me when he played with staples in his throwing hand.

 

[QuiGon]

I have always considered Drew Bledsoe to be one of the toughest QBs ever. I mean this guy gets sacked 5-6 times per game. (5 or 6 sacks was a season for Marino). Bledsoe's lack of mobility means taking constant shots.

And after all that punishment, he has only missed serious playing time due to injury once in his career.

 

[sdaniels7114]

Gotta respect Bledsoe. He left the hospital after recovering from the Lewis hit and went straight to Foxboro, not home. I agree about the lack of mental toughness though too.