- Joined
- Dec 22, 2008
- Messages
- 15,689
- Reaction score
- 17,163
Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.Peyton Manning is considered "3rd" in most peoples eyes now!
Do you agree with this?
Isn't this a "pick your poison" question?Peyton Manning is considered "3rd" in most peoples eyes now!
Do you agree with this?
Isn't this a "pick your poison" question?
I don't know that the results of this Super Bowl is a positive. Now Pats fans will not only hear from Colts fans / Pats haters that Peyton Manning is better than Brady, but we will also hear from Steeler fans / Pats haters that Roethlisberger is better, or at least more clutch than Brady (and that the Steelers are superior to the Pats.)
Rothlesbooger was great on that last drive, and he certainly was very good in the face of pressure on Sunday night, but it is laughable to elevate him above Manning, Brady, or anyone of a number of past QB greats. Ben has a great team around him, he isn't asked to do to much, and when in doubt, he can always rely on the D. "most" peoples eyes? Who?Peyton Manning is considered "3rd" in most peoples eyes now!
Do you agree with this?
Or better yet, Pats fans may be hearing James Harrison >>> Richard Seymour for at least another 8 months...why Harrison is better than Seymour b/c he's supposedly not only a better playmaker, but supposedly a better game breaker, who also supposedly forces more holding calls on him.
No Roethlisberger isn't better than Manning. In the playoffs maybe, but not overall. Manning really hasn't performed as well in the playoffs as he has in the regular season.
And Harrison is better than Seymour.
who cares who considers manning to be third best the best whatever. its all about the team winning Superbowl's. i dont care if the so called experts think brady is garbage as long as the team wins.Peyton Manning is considered "3rd" in most peoples eyes now!
Do you agree with this?
ben is a decent game manager but it's the d that wins.
Roethlisberger did nothing in his first Super Bowl win. I think P. Manning still is the better QB.