He wasn't "fine". He was inconsistent before his injury as I posted in another thread. These things happen to all RBs, that's just one of the reasons I don't believe in drafting them in the 1st round.
Gostowski was a gamble. All rookie kickers are. It paid off. Moreover, I applauded the team for not caving into AV and Meion's demands. However, the 2006 draft will be judged on the success of Laurence and Chad. If these guys fail, this draft will go down as a disaster.
I do like Thomas. I will discuss him later in this post.
As I posted, OC dropped because of his injury history. I agree that if healthy, OC will be a steal.
Andrews is a good gunner, but it's hardly something to hang your hat on.
I liked the 2005 draft under the circumstances: poor talent pool and picking last in every round. However, the Pats wound up with only a Guard in the 1st round. Mankins is a work in progress, but you can always get Guards. That's been an axiom since the Pats let Woody and Andruzzi walk.
The jury is still out on Kaczur, who was terrible in the SD game and the Pats were unable to run to his side.
Actually, the 2006 draft is still subject to review you really can't say it turned out good. IMO, this draft is starting out on the wrong foot. If the '06 draft doesn't pan out (i.e. Maroney and Jackson are busts), that will make 2 poor drafts in the past 3 years - not a good track record.
I'm going to be blunt and say Watson sucks. He's an awful blocker, drops way too many passes, doesn't usually get open, and developed a case a fumble-itus. In the second half of the season, I cringed every time a pass was thrown his way. His per game numbers were dropping when Brady developed chemistry with the WRs.
Now for David Thomas. Getting him the 3rd round was a steal. He's a bit undersized and needs work on his blocking, but he improved in this area as the season progressed. In the Rose Bowl a year ago, I was impressed with both his ability to hold onto the ball after getting hit (something Watson doesn't do well), and his penchant for getting open. The Jags game showed that he can be a great check off receiver over the middle. Why the team never went to him after that game is beyond me. I will dare say that Thomas is a better player than Watson right now.
Again I will be blunt. Gusssss sucksssss. Every time he played with the regular defense, he'd limp off the field after making a tackle. Moreover, in the regular defense, Gussss showed that he couldn't cover and had zero ball skills. Against SD in the 41-17 loss, Gussss allowed a TD where he stood starting at ball w/o so much as lifting up his arm. The fact that he couldn't play in the NFL is echoed by his failure to stick with the Texans and Jets. To think we passed up on players like Gibril Wilson and Shaun Phillips to take this guy.
Reid was another guy who can't play safety in the NFL. He almost cost us SB 39 when he allowed a 30-yard TD to Greg Lewis to make it a 24-21 game. He had a chance to redeem himself in TC the following summer, but the Pats knew he couldn't play and let him go. As for his contributions with Indy, there's no way he'll crack the lineup with Sanders, Jackson, and Bethea on the depth chart. He's been nothing but a gunner on STs. We know how good his unit fared in SB 41.
PK Sam is another player that can't stick on a roster. He's now with the Dolphins where he'll probably fail another "numbers crunch".
I thought Hill was a great pick at the time, but I accuse the Pats of substituting diligent scouting with their connections to coaches. This mistake might be repeated with Chad Jackson, IMO. The Pats have taken some hits in their scouting department since 2003 and I wonder if it's affecting them.
If Laurence/Chad are busts, it will be 2 bad drafts in 3 years. Not good.