If everyone who voted in that poll had the chance to start their own franchise,and were hooked up to lie detectors...I'd wager 99.99999% of them would take Brady over Calvin Johnson..if only out of abject fear of being exposed as total morons.
I'd take Rodgers first because of his scrambling ability, quick release and accuracy. Although this doesn't factor in the rankings, the thing that worries me most about Rodgers is his concussion history.
Brees is definitely 3rd behind Brady. Not even an argument IMO.