The Brady > Mahomes thread - It's not even close

[SHOWTIME15]

Boys, hop on the bandwagon with the Future Goat...

 

[Guts]

Boys, hop on the bandwagon with the Future Goat...

Nah never, but that is an insane stat.

 

[SHOWTIME15]

Nah never, but that is an insane stat.

Most impressive QB I've ever seen play

 

[sb1]

We still talking about the guy who has never beaten Brady when it matters? Neat!

 

[PATS16N0]

That's why we are only comparing their first five years as starter.

You’re comparing old era football to the post Peyton-rule-change-era that made for crazy yardage. This probably after years of arguing ToM iSn’T aS gOoD aS mOnTaNa BeCaUsE eRaS.

Go follow “RandomTomBradyHighlights” on Twitter. Despite media narratives, Tom Brady was ALWAYS that ****ing guy. All the stuff Mahomes does only with way more results.

 

[Guts]

You’re comparing old era football to the post Peyton-rule-change-era that made for crazy yardage. This probably after years of arguing ToM iSn’T aS gOoD aS mOnTaNa BeCaUsE eRaS.

Go follow “RandomTomBradyHighlights” on Twitter. Despite media narratives, Tom Brady was ALWAYS that ****ing guy. All the stuff Mahomes does only with way more results.

I think my boy Mac 10/TommyBrady12 is at Kansas City training camp so he hasn't been around lately

 

[stinkypete]

He's still a long ways off. The only way he can surpass Brady, short of besting Brady's records, is to accomplish something extraordinary that Brady hasn't done.

If the Chiefs three-peat, I predict we start hearing some chatter from the major media players.

 

[Guts]

He's still a long ways off. The only way he can surpass Brady, short of besting Brady's records, is to accomplish something extraordinary that Brady hasn't done.

If the Chiefs three-peat, I predict we start hearing some chatter from the major media players.

If he three peats and gets to like 5 or 6 then it could be a conversation

Could be

 

[The Brandon Five]

If he three peats and gets to like 5 or 6 then it could be a conversation

Could be

If he is facing Shanahan again he has a chance since Kyle loves to abandon the run when his team has the lead in the SB.

 

[1960Pats]

He's still a long ways off. The only way he can surpass Brady, short of besting Brady's records, is to accomplish something extraordinary that Brady hasn't done.

If the Chiefs three-peat, I predict we start hearing some chatter from the major media players.

We should hear it if they threepeat. That would be a great accomplishment, even if they didn't have to face any top QBs.

 

[SlowGettingUp]

A reminder of Brady's play:

 

[stinkypete]

If he three peats and gets to like 5 or 6 then it could be a conversation

Could be

The only way I see that being enough is if he gets to 5 or 6 in a remarkably short period of time then retires in his prime. Then you can argue that Mahomes' extended run of brilliance beats Brady's two hall of fame careers with a dry spell in the middle. It would be a fun argument, I'm sure we'd all love it.

I am interested to see how much longer this stretch of KC dominating the AFC can sustain itself. I see no reason to believe another team is better this coming year.

 

[sb1]

Brady is so awesome <3 <3 <3

Sincerely,
@SHOWTIME15

 

[sb1]

The only way I see that being enough is if he gets to 5 or 6 in a remarkably short period of time then retires in his prime. Then you can argue that Mahomes' extended run of brilliance beats Brady's two hall of fame careers with a dry spell in the middle. It would be a fun argument, I'm sure we'd all love it.

I am interested to see how much longer this stretch of KC dominating the AFC can sustain itself. I see no reason to believe another team is better this coming year.

Kermit is 0-2 vs the GOAT in games that matter. He'll have to do something REALLY special to overcome that. I doubt he will.

 

[1960Pats]

Kermit is 0-2 vs the GOAT in games that matter. He'll have to do something REALLY special to overcome that. I doubt he will.

If Mahomes gets the threepeat then that will be really special, even though he will have done it against easier opposition than Brady faced. I don't see any other team that's a real threat.

 

[1960Pats]

The only way I see that being enough is if he gets to 5 or 6 in a remarkably short period of time then retires in his prime. Then you can argue that Mahomes' extended run of brilliance beats Brady's two hall of fame careers with a dry spell in the middle. It would be a fun argument, I'm sure we'd all love it.

I am interested to see how much longer this stretch of KC dominating the AFC can sustain itself. I see no reason to believe another team is better this coming year.

In spite of how great he's done so far, Mahomes is still trailing Brady's first run. A threepeat this year would change that and put Brady well within reach for Mahomes, something that I didn't believe could happen a few years ago.

 

[Not-A-Chiefs-Fan]

We still talking about the guy who has never beaten Brady when it matters? Neat!

I gotta hand it to Brady, he retired at the perfect moment. Mahomes could go on to win 8 SBs and cement himself as the best ever, but there will always be those two championship games where he couldn't beat Brady. Respect.

 

[borg]

Just a few stats

Brady SB winning rate.....67% (6/9)
Maholmes.............................75% (3/4)

Brady playoff winning rate ....74% (31-11)
Maholmes.....................................83% (15-3)

Biggest drought without winning a ring
Brady 9 years
Mahomes 2 years

 

[sb1]

I gotta hand it to Brady, he retired at the perfect moment. Mahomes could go on to win 8 SBs and cement himself as the best ever, but there will always be those two championship games where he couldn't beat Brady. Respect.

Brady has that "trump card" in this conversation.. so I think Mahomes has to accomplish something really special to exceed not just equal Tom.

A threepeat will help. 8 rings might do it on its own. Long way off of course....

 

[sb1]

Just a few stats

Brady SB winning rate.....67% (6/9)

7/10... 70%

Maholmes.............................75% (3/4)

With the 1 loss being a complete blowout by... Brady's team. Brady never lost a SB by more than 5 points.

Brady playoff winning rate ....74% (31-11)
Maholmes.....................................83% (15-3)

Biggest drought without winning a ring
Brady 9 years
Mahomes 2 years

More SB stats

QBR
Brady - 97.7
Mahomes - 85.2

TD/INT
Brady - 21/6
Mahomes - 7/5

300+ yard games
Brady - 4 in 10 games
Mahomes - 1 in 4 games