Lets look at our starting offense from SB 39 and who replaced them with an upgrade/downgrade rating:
Givens, David WR - Replaced by Caldwell/Jackson -(for now) downgrade
Light, Matt LT - still here
Andruzzi, Joe LG - Replaced by Mankins - upgrade
Koppen, Dan C - Still here
Neal, Steve RG - Still here
Gorin, Brandon RT - O'callaghan - upgrade
Graham, Daniel TE - still here this would be Watson - Upgrade
Branch, Deion WR - Gabriel - (for Now) downgrade
Brady, Tom QB - Still here
Dillon, Corey RB - Still here
Pass, Patrick FB - Still here but this would be Graham - Upgrade
5 starter's have changed and 3 for the better. RT is better simply because of the overall depth on the line. Pass is still with the team on the PUP. The only place they are feeling the pinch is at WR and no one knows how that will end up.
Now lets look at the defense:
Seymour, Richard DE - Still here
Wilfork, Vince NT - Still here
Green, Jarvis DE - Still here - replaced by Warren - Upgrade
McGinest, Willie OLB - Replaced by Colvin - due to age - Upgrade
Bruschi, Tedy ILB - Still here
Johnson, Ted ILB - Replaced by Seau - downgrade against the run
Vrabel, Mike OLB - Still here
Gay, Randall LCB - Still here - Replaced by Hobbs - Upgrade
Samuel, Asante RCB - Still here
Harrison, Rodney SS - Still here
Wilson, Eugene FS - Still here
Two starters from SB 39 are gone one to retirement and one left via FA and was not going to start this season. Two starters from that defense have become depth at their position.
Six starters out of the 22 are no longer with this team and the only two that can be considered a downgrade are the wide receivers. This team has added depth at every position except for LB and as a whole they have become a better team. The WR corps is a work in progress that should continue to get better each week. Reche has been decent, Gabriel has shown the ability to get open and catch the balls thrown to him and Brown is his trusty old self. Jackson and Gaffney are the two enigma's at this point and a healthy Jackson will hopefully be a solid number 2 WR option this season.
Key departures from ST:
AV
Matt
??
I am sure I am missing some others as well.
Does anyone think that the veteran's suddenly forgot what it takes to win?
I don't understand how people don't feel that this is a better team than the 2004 Pats. The only arguments that make sense to me are:
The rookie kicker argument: I agree it has to be a concern until Gost proves he can kick the game winner in the playoffs. Fortunately with the potential of this offense and the way the defense has been playing we shouldn't have to find out.
WR argument: Nobody knows how this will end up, so it is a mute point at this moment.
LB depth: The most valid argument of the three and if one of our starters gets injured then we get into the great unknown. Tully to the outside and Vrabel or ??? into the middle with a lot of inexperienced depth behind them.
They are deeper at both lines, RB, TE and DB. I believe their is more talent at WR just not the chemistry and proven playoff experience.
Overall this team is as good as any team in the NFL and they have yet to get their passing game together. When/if it does this team will be nearly unstoppable.