I looked it up because I was curious. Wilson really hasn't done much since his super bowl loss. A pretty massive under performance for all the talk about him. He has yet to reach the NFCCG since losing to the Patriots. He's been to the playoffs 5 out of 6 years without a losing season which is good.... but you need to actually make a deep run or people will likely question you. Here are his 5 loses in the playoffs since the SB.
DIV 2015 @ CAR - He tossed 2 early picks (including a pick 6) which gave up 10 points. The other one happened in FG range. He did nothing the first half while his team fell 0-31. He scored in the 2nd half but he dug his hole too deep and lost 24-31.
DIV 2016 @ ATL - He didn't have a good game here either. Though this one is a bit more on his D. He lost 36-20. This one kind of got away from the Seahawks in the 2nd and early 3rd quarter. Wilson taking a safety wasn't REALLY his fault, but you if you get your foot stepped on and fall back into the end zone maybe your footwork could use some work. While I don't put this loss on him, he did fail to elevate his team. Maybe he couldn't win, but it could have been closer. At least he could have kept within striking distance in the 4th with a few more plays made. It's telling that Hester the returner may well have been the most impactful player for the Seahawks this game.
2017 MISSED
WC 2018 @ DAL - This game is on Wilson. He didn't throw it away, he was just ineffective. They had 12 possessions and score 20 points, half of it on short fields. His stats look nice at 18/27 233 yards 1 pass TD 1 rush TD and 0 turnovers. But this is a case of just kind of waiting around to win. 2/13 on 3rd down was huge. You don't win many games when that happens. Interestingly, this is the only post season win for Dak an the cowboys. Wilson and the Seahawks allowed them to play exactly the kind of game they wanted to. A nice slow, run the ball grind it out in the 4th kind of game. It's also worth noting this game was 14-17 until the final few minutes. Dallas scored to put it out of reach at 14-24. The Seahakws do a big drive quickly and then fail to get the onside kick. There was just no urgency to score points until it was too late. 22-24
DIV 2019 @ GB - Another slow start. They end the half down 3-21. Allowing Rodgers and GB to play from ahead the rest of the way. Wilson leads another almost come back which makes his stats look amazing but stalls at the end. Interestingly the Seahawks DOMINATED TOP in the 2nd half, and were happy to have nice long drives down 3-21 and then 10-28. There was a huge lack of urgency here from Wilson and the Seahwks. You don't settled for drives of 5+ minutes when you are down multiple TDs in the second half. Wilson again ends up with a nice stat line and almost heroic come back, but it seems he didn't understand the need for urgency.
WC 2020 LAR @ SEA - This game really is about 2 plays for Wilson. The pick 6 and the 50 yard TD to Metcalf. Outside of that it was kind of just a 'wait for my team to win' game for him, even as they were slowly pushed further behind in the 2nd half. A late TD drive helps his stats but he basically did nothing all game besides that big TD pass until garbage time. The Rams have a good D, but this is not good enough.
Overall Wilson's entire career is really built around that first run in the playoffs on that absolutely dynamic D and with great weapons around him. Outside of that, in the playoffs when you really look at it he has lacked a sense of the moment and a willingness to kind of sit back and hope it works out. His almost comebacks always seem to be too little or too late. The fact of the matter is besides his super bowl run, he has been pretty choky in the playoffs. His appearence in 2014 to play the Patriots only happened because as hard as he choked in the 2015 NFCCG vs GB, Rodgers choked even harder.
When you really examine his career it is built on 2 of the biggest choke jobs of all time happening against him (Peyton and Rodgers) when he didn't really play well in either of those games. This isn't to say he isn't HOF level, but he doesn't lift up his team very often. At this point I don't see him being in the top 10 discussion unless we see some massive changes in his play over his final 6-9 years
