Off-topic - back to on-topic.
Those arguing TO go to the HoF point to his receiving stats - the best after Jerry Rice. But we know over the past 30 years the rules have opened up the passing game A LOT. If you go by the statistics, TO is way better than Lynn Swan for instance....yeah, that sounds fishy.
The statistics as they relate to Peyton Manning. His passing stats are impressive, but again the rules makes it a lot easier to complete a pass than it was for Johnny Unitas or even Joe Montana. I'd do like MLB and compare his stats to players of his era. This also makes the playoff record and other intangibles more important. You already know the verdict on Peyton: good, but not the best.