PatsFans.com Menu
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans

NFL removes replay authority from on-field referee


Status
Not open for further replies.
I am fine with it. It serves no one to rig the games and i think it makes college games go smoother. I am fine with this. Speed it along.

In the end as long as we know the name of the ref making the final call and it falls on one guy it is fine. The Key is to have someone able to be held accountable.
 
I am fine with it. It serves no one to rig the games and i think it makes college games go smoother. I am fine with this. Speed it along.

In the end as long as we know the name of the ref making the final call and it falls on one guy it is fine. The Key is to have someone able to be held accountable.

Since when has the NFL ever been held to that standard?

It sure as hell won't be Blandinko, whose breath smells like Goody's underwear.
 
All aboard the Cowboy Party Bus! I'll the take dem 'Boys and give ya 10 1/2 . . .

I wonder how many blow calls Blandino will have.

upload_2017-3-23_17-3-4.png

upload_2017-3-23_17-3-36.png

upload_2017-3-23_17-4-0.png
 
This league.
Turning into a very transparent but sad joke.

Pretty soon people will be voting in who they want to win based on hatred and coolest uniforms.

american-idol-voting.jpg
 
I don't think it's totally reasonable to assume this is some overt attempt at centralizing power in order to fix games or anything. If the league wanted to fix games against the Pats, they could've fixed SB51 in about a hundred different ways to ensure we didn't finish that comeback. That's not the issue. The issue, in my eyes, is that Dean Blandino will be the one making the final call, and that I don't think there's any reasonable basis for claiming that he's better equipped to make replay calls than the refs on the field. As it is with just about everything the NFL does, I foresee a sloppy rollout, miserable execution, and inevitable controversy. All for a 'solution' that probably wouldn't fix anything in the first place.

It's highly unlikely for there to be multiple simultaneous plays needing replay review.

It's not that unlikely, considering how many games are played in the early Sunday time slot. It will happen, and it will probably happen pretty soon (within the first month of the season would be my guess). I would bet money that they have not even considered, let alone meaningfully accounted for, this eventuality. Because 'foresight' and 'league office' do not belong in the same sentence.
 
Last edited:
I don't necessarily have a problem with the league centralizing the process or otherwise taking it out of the hands of the on field ref. It's worked fairly well in the NHL. HOWEVER making Blandino the final arbitor is a huge mistake. Making a guy who has never actually reffed a game the head of officials is suspect to begin with. Making him the final arbitor of every challenge, is another example of Goodell's hubris at its worst.

Given that there are three stand alone game each week (Sunday night, Monday night, and Thursday) plus a bye week after game 2; there are 12 games going on most Sundays. I would assume that would mean 6 early games and 6 late games each week. If we assume there are just 2 challenges every game; that would mean Blandino would be making the call on at least 12 plays during each time frame. As mentioned so many time before in the this thread "What could possible go wrong with that??.:rolleyes:

BTW- while its unlikely that there will be 2 or more challenges at the same time, there will have to be a plan for when it happens. What is that plan and who will make that discision.

Questions: On average, how many challenges actually occur in each game? There can be as many as 6, but my guess would be somewhere between 2-3/game. So what are the actual stats?

How does this policy affect the so called booth reviews that happen in the last 2 minutes of each half? Are thoe calls being centralized too?

It's usually 8 games in the early Sunday slot, at least at the beginning and end of the season when there are no byes. I think we'll see the multiple-reviews issue pop up a lot sooner than people here are guessing. I'd bet it'll happen within the first month of the season, when you consider how many games will be hitting the final two minutes of both halves right around the same time.
 
Trainwreck waitng to happen...just wait till there r 2 or 3 reviews at the same time pending Blandinos decision
 
Trainwreck waitng to happen...just wait till there r 2 or 3 reviews at the same time pending Blandinos decision
I just read where there will be 2 other "qualified" people in the booth with Blandino in case this happens. So when you think about, there won't be a problem.....except for the Blandino thing. ;)
 
Oh for the love of god. It wont matter if ten calls have to be made.. Dean and roger will only be watching one game.
 
Trainwreck waitng to happen...just wait till there r 2 or 3 reviews at the same time pending Blandinos decision
As if ''Blandino'' doesn't mean ''Blandino and a small team of interns''
 
I don't necessarily have a problem with the league centralizing the process or otherwise taking it out of the hands of the on field ref. It's worked fairly well in the NHL. HOWEVER making Blandino the final arbitor is a huge mistake. Making a guy who has never actually reffed a game the head of officials is suspect to begin with. Making him the final arbitor of every challenge, is another example of Goodell's hubris at its worst.

Given that there are three stand alone game each week (Sunday night, Monday night, and Thursday) plus a bye week after game 2; there are 12 games going on most Sundays. I would assume that would mean 6 early games and 6 late games each week. If we assume there are just 2 challenges every game; that would mean Blandino would be making the call on at least 12 plays during each time frame. As mentioned so many time before in the this thread "What could possible go wrong with that??.:rolleyes:

BTW- while its unlikely that there will be 2 or more challenges at the same time, there will have to be a plan for when it happens. What is that plan and who will make that discision.

Questions: On average, how many challenges actually occur in each game? There can be as many as 6, but my guess would be somewhere between 2-3/game. So what are the actual stats?

How does this policy affect the so called booth reviews that happen in the last 2 minutes of each half? Are thoe calls being centralized too?

Lots of stats in this article.. I don't really know how credible this site is, but they reference Pro Football Reference and some other sites for their data

Breaking down an average NFL game.

The 7th paragraph suggests 1.6 reviews per game, but I haven't yet found anything else to confirm nor deny it, so take it for what its worth

The game will be stopped. A lot. There will be 8.9 penalties and 1.6 reviews and about 55 percent will come from the replay booth. Of the reviews triggered by the replay booth, 58 percent will be upheld. Coach's challenges will be more successful, as just less than half will be upheld. These reviews will take a total of 3 minutes and 30 seconds, or 2:08 per review (this data comes from my own timing of 48 reviews this year).

Disclaimer: Apparently these stats are from the 2013 NFL season, so a bit outdated
 
Last edited:
I just read where there will be 2 other "qualified" people in the booth with Blandino in case this happens. So when you think about, there won't be a problem.....except for the Blandino thing. ;)
Kensil and Pash?:rolleyes:
 
guys how could this POSSIBLY backfire
 
Ted wells will be helping.


I retract my comment from the other day when i said ryan going to espn being the ultimate nightmare. They managed one better. Id rather kim jong un make all the calls as it would inspire more confidence.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.


Bruschi’s Proudest Moment: Former LB Speaks to MusketFire’s Marshall in Recent Interview
Monday Patriots Notebook 4/22: News and Notes
Patriots News 4-21, Kraft-Belichick, A.J. Brown Trade?
MORSE: Patriots Draft Needs and Draft Related Info
Friday Patriots Notebook 4/19: News and Notes
TRANSCRIPT: Eliot Wolf’s Pre-Draft Press Conference 4/18/24
Thursday Patriots Notebook 4/18: News and Notes
Wednesday Patriots Notebook 4/17: News and Notes
Tuesday Patriots Notebook 4/16: News and Notes
Monday Patriots Notebook 4/15: News and Notes
Back
Top