Let's judge young QBs by their Mic'd Up segments

[slam]

It's bye week, so lets watch a different type of film. Let's take a look at the available Mic'd up segments of the prized QBs of the last few drafts and make unfair judgments on their leadership skills based on a tiny, highly edited sample size. Who's in?

Baker Mayfield


Sam Darnold


Josh Allen
N/A

Josh Rosen
N/A

Mitchell Trubisky


Patrick Mahomes


Dashaun Watson

 

[slam]

Jared Goff


Carson Wentz


I haven't watched them all yet, but from what I've seen so far I think Mayfield and Mahomes relate very well to their teammates. Mayfield just seems fun to be around and "one of the guys". Darnold seems to be uninspiring. He mouths encouragement but it seems perfunctory, insincere, and lacking in charisma.

I apologize that I couldn't find a Nathan Peterman Mic'd Up.

 

[long distance]

interesting idea, nice collection

 

[Tony2046]

It's bye week, so lets watch a different type of film. Let's take a look at the available Mic'd up segments of the prized QBs of the last few drafts and make unfair judgments on their leadership skills based on a tiny, highly edited sample size. Who's in?

Baker Mayfield


Sam Darnold


Josh Allen
N/A

Josh Rosen
N/A

Mitchell Trubisky


Patrick Mahomes


Dashaun Watson

Very cool thread. Thanks for putting this together.

 

[maust]

I apologize that I couldn't find a Nathan Peterman Mic'd Up.

NFL Films labored long and hard at putting a Peterman segment together but in spite of intensive effort all they could come up with was a blooper reel of plays to a soundtrack of Peterman saying "Oh (bleep), AHH (BLEEP), WHAT THE (BLEEP)!!! and MOTHER(BLEEPER)!!!

 

[RobertWeathers]

I haven't watched them all either but your instincts are spot on. Show me a QB who commands the huddle, inspires his teammates and is smart with the football and I'll show you a winning QB.

I was wrong about Mayfield. I thought he was a punk. The kid has it. He'll be good for years to come.

 

[nabwong]

I apologize that I couldn't find a Nathan Peterman Mic'd Up.

Found it.

 

[slam]

Lest we forget, Jimmy G


Marcus Mariota


Jameis Winston


Jimmy G's was his first start with the Niners. Acting like he's been there for years.