Is Caldwell done?

[Kdo5]

Gaffney is better than Caldwell. And more reliable.
Plus he is better under pressure.

It should be no contest.

That is BS and you are a big f**king joke, Keegs. Gaffney showed he was reliable in two games. Caldwell showed that against Tennessee, against the Jets, against the Chargers, and against the Vikings. Gaffney has never been tested under pressure, idiot. Caldwell was clutch against San Diego. Gaffney didnt do squat in the regular season. He had a big game vs the Chargers and then had the fantastic 3 catches versus the Colts.

You are so full of ****, Keegs. Unbelievable.

 

[PATSNUTme]

 

[Keegs]

That is BS and you are a big f**king joke, Keegs. Gaffney showed he was reliable in two games. Caldwell showed that against Tennessee, against the Jets, against the Chargers, and against the Vikings. Gaffney has never been tested under pressure, idiot. Caldwell was clutch against San Diego. Gaffney didnt do squat in the regular season. He had a big game vs the Chargers and then had the fantastic 3 catches versus the Colts.

You are so full of ****, Keegs. Unbelievable.

WOW who ran over your dog? jeez. And no swearing please.
Now to my response.

It's not BS and yes i may be a f-ing joke. But Gaffney is better. Reche may have had better regular season stats but Gaffney only started 6 games compared to Caldwell's 14. You don't have to be Normal Einstein to see that Caldwell is obviously going to have better regular season numbers.
Lets observe there playoff performances shall we?? After all, that is when it is most important : right this way gentlemen............:singing:

hmm lets seee here....
Gaffney vs. Jets 8 rec. 104 yds
vs. SD 10 rec. 103 yds 1 td
vs. Indy 3 rec. 37 yds 1 td 0 chokes
TOTAL: 21 rec. 242 yds 2tds 0 chokes

Caldwell vs. Jets 5 rec. 50 yds
vs. SD 7 rec. 80 yds 1 td
vs. Indy 4 rec. 46 yds 2 chokes
TOTAL: 16 rec. 176 yds 1 td 2 chokes

As you can see, i am right. As usual.
Even if you take away the 2 drops that my Nana would have caught, Gaffney is still better when it MATTERS THE MOST.

I rest my case.:woohoo:

thanks and be sure to tip your waitress..

 

[gomezcat]

Is this the "No way...makes the team" thread for this year? I'd be willing to bet that he does make the team.

 

[Clonamery]

WOW who ran over your dog? jeez. And no swearing please.
Now to my response.

It's not BS and yes i may be a f-ing joke. But Gaffney is better. Reche may have had better regular season stats but Gaffney only started 6 games compared to Caldwell's 14. You don't have to be Normal Einstein to see that Caldwell is obviously going to have better regular season numbers.
Lets observe there playoff performances shall we?? After all, that is when it is most important : right this way gentlemen............:singing:

hmm lets seee here....
Gaffney vs. Jets 8 rec. 104 yds
vs. SD 10 rec. 103 yds 1 td
vs. Indy 3 rec. 37 yds 1 td 0 chokes
TOTAL: 21 rec. 242 yds 2tds 0 chokes

Caldwell vs. Jets 5 rec. 50 yds
vs. SD 7 rec. 80 yds 1 td
vs. Indy 4 rec. 46 yds 2 chokes
TOTAL: 16 rec. 176 yds 1 td 2 chokes

As you can see, i am right. As usual.
Even if you take away the 2 drops that my Nana would have caught, Gaffney is still better when it MATTERS THE MOST.

I rest my case.:woohoo:

thanks and be sure to tip your waitress..

Your intellect proves your egotism, your sarcasm, your ability to regurgitate numbers, and fathom issues at a passing depth.

Surely you must consider political office, O Trite One!

 

[Keegs]

Your intellect proves your egotism, your sarcasm, your ability to regurgitate numbers, and fathom issues at a passing depth.

Surely you must consider political office, O Trite One!

You try to hard.
Explain how what I typed is wrong.
that is all you have to do

 

[Keegs]

WOW who ran over your dog? jeez. And no swearing please.
Now to my response.

It's not BS and yes i may be a f-ing joke. But Gaffney is better. Reche may have had better regular season stats but Gaffney only started 6 games compared to Caldwell's 14. You don't have to be Normal Einstein to see that Caldwell is obviously going to have better regular season numbers.
Lets observe there playoff performances shall we?? After all, that is when it is most important : right this way gentlemen............:singing:

hmm lets seee here....
Gaffney vs. Jets 8 rec. 104 yds
vs. SD 10 rec. 103 yds 1 td
vs. Indy 3 rec. 37 yds 1 td 0 chokes
TOTAL: 21 rec. 242 yds 2tds 0 chokes

Caldwell vs. Jets 5 rec. 50 yds
vs. SD 7 rec. 80 yds 1 td
vs. Indy 4 rec. 46 yds 2 chokes
TOTAL: 16 rec. 176 yds 1 td 2 chokes

As you can see, i am right. As usual.
Even if you take away the 2 drops that my Nana would have caught, Gaffney is still better when it MATTERS THE MOST.

I rest my case.:woohoo:

thanks and be sure to tip your waitress..

can any of you Caldwell supporters disprove this?

Gaffney is the better receiver when it matters most.

 

[shmessy]

WOW who ran over your dog? jeez. And no swearing please.
Now to my response.

It's not BS and yes i may be a f-ing joke. But Gaffney is better. Reche may have had better regular season stats but Gaffney only started 6 games compared to Caldwell's 14. You don't have to be Normal Einstein to see that Caldwell is obviously going to have better regular season numbers.
Lets observe there playoff performances shall we?? After all, that is when it is most important : right this way gentlemen............:singing:

hmm lets seee here....
Gaffney vs. Jets 8 rec. 104 yds
vs. SD 10 rec. 103 yds 1 td
vs. Indy 3 rec. 37 yds 1 td 0 chokes
TOTAL: 21 rec. 242 yds 2tds 0 chokes

Caldwell vs. Jets 5 rec. 50 yds
vs. SD 7 rec. 80 yds 1 td
vs. Indy 4 rec. 46 yds 2 chokes
TOTAL: 16 rec. 176 yds 1 td 2 chokes

As you can see, i am right. As usual.
Even if you take away the 2 drops that my Nana would have caught, Gaffney is still better when it MATTERS THE MOST.

I rest my case.:woohoo:

thanks and be sure to tip your waitress..

3 Games. You could probably make an argument for anyone to be a better player based on 3 games.

As a CFP, I work with many people everyday who overreact to the stock market on short term ups and downs. People who make decisions based on a small sampling tend to lose.

 

[Keegs]

3 Games. You could probably make an argument for anyone to be a better player based on 3 games.

As a CFP, I work with many people everyday who overreact to the stock market on short term ups and downs. People who make decisions based on a small sampling tend to lose.

These are the only playoff games that they could compared on.
Next year we can add more playoff games.

You cannot compare regular season games b/c Caldwell started in over twice as many as Gaffney.

They were both prepared and ready to go in the playoffs and Gaffney performed on a higher level.

I am saying that Gaffney is a better receiver when it matters the most; playoff time. And that is a fact until proven otherwise.

 

[shmessy]

These are the only playoff games that they could compared on.
Next year we can add more playoff games.

You cannot compare regular season games b/c Caldwell started in over twice as many as Gaffney.

They were both prepared and ready to go in the playoffs and Gaffney performed on a higher level.

I am saying that Gaffney is a better receiver when it matters the most; playoff time. And that is a fact until proven otherwise.

January 2007 Playoffs:

Lawrence Maroney:
-----------------
ATT-31 Yds-87 Avg-2.8 TD-0

Corey Dillon:
-----------
ATT-25 Yds-119 Avg-4.8 TD-2


Gee whiz, Keegs, looks like BB/Pioli got rid of the wrong runningback, huh?

 

[salty]

Hmm...who will I trust more?

The one who has watched, planned, reviewed, taught, and learned from every second of every Patriots game in the past 6 years?

Or the one who is making generalized and false statements based on little or no film review?

The 3-time Super Bowl champion Bill Belichick?

Or the agenda-driven, delusional salty?

So...you don't agree with me?

 

[Kdo5]

WOW who ran over your dog? jeez. And no swearing please.
Now to my response.

It's not BS and yes i may be a f-ing joke. But Gaffney is better. Reche may have had better regular season stats but Gaffney only started 6 games compared to Caldwell's 14. You don't have to be Normal Einstein to see that Caldwell is obviously going to have better regular season numbers.
Lets observe there playoff performances shall we?? After all, that is when it is most important : right this way gentlemen............:singing:

Always wanted to do that Keegs. But as I can see just like good arguments and evidence it bounces right off of you. Eat crow when Caldwell has way way more receptions than Gaffney does next year. Also eat crow when Caldwell starts the entire season.

 

[Keegs]

January 2007 Playoffs:

Lawrence Maroney:
-----------------
ATT-31 Yds-87 Avg-2.8 TD-0

Corey Dillon:
-----------
ATT-25 Yds-119 Avg-4.8 TD-2


Gee whiz, Keegs, looks like BB/Pioli got rid of the wrong runningback, huh?

no. but it can be argued now that Dillon is a better running back in the playoffs, when it matters most. I'm sure the playoff experience has helped him over Maroney.

However, Maroney didn't have any huge boneheaded plays, Caldwell had 2

 

[salty]

Dropping those Ridiculously easy Passes is not like missing a field goal.

If Gostkowski missed a 20 yard field goal (the equivalent), then yes, i would say he is unreliable too.

Actually, a better analogy would have been if Gostkowski had missed TWO 20 yard field goals in the AFC Championship game. Remember, Reche messed up on TWO easy TD passes in that game.

Can you imagine if the Ghost had missed two 20 yard field goals? He would've been roasted alive. "We should've kept Vinatieri!" everybody would have screamed. But yet, Reche gets a free ride. I don't get it.

 

[Keegs]

Actually, a better analogy would have been if Gostkowski had missed TWO 20 yard field goals in the AFC Championship game. Remember, Reche messed up on TWO easy TD passes in that game.

Can you imagine if the Ghost had missed two 20 yard field goals? He would've been roasted alive. "We should've kept Vinatieri!" everybody would have screamed. But yet, Reche gets a free ride. I don't get it.

i don't either it's garbage...

I'm not helping you out much though. We both agree on this but since my username is "keegs" and many posters on here can't stand me, they will do anything in their power to make it so i am not right. This includes lying to themselves and making Reche Caldwell out to be the second coming of Jerry Rice.:singing:

God im tired of always being right on here.

 

[AzPatsFan]

Caldwell won't be cut.

Next question.

Ditto !! ditto ditto

 

[shmessy]

no. but it can be argued now that Dillon is a better running back in the playoffs, when it matters most. I'm sure the playoff experience has helped him over Maroney.

However, Maroney didn't have any huge boneheaded plays, Caldwell had 2

Arguing that Dillon is generally a better playoff RB is ridiculous. Three games does not make a trend.

I just blasted your 3 game judgement out of the water by exposing the Maroney-Dillon stat lines.

Short-term, knee-jerk reactions are a prescription for failure. Stay away from the stock market, kid.

 

[Kdo5]

no. but it can be argued now that Dillon is a better running back in the playoffs, when it matters most. I'm sure the playoff experience has helped him over Maroney.

However, Maroney didn't have any huge boneheaded plays, Caldwell had 2

I see you saying Gaffney is clutch or something along those lines. He was great in TWO PLAYOFF GAMES. two, TWO! And he never made the big catch at the end of the game did he? But Gaffney was with us since around the second Buffalo game, which was early on. He had all that time to become a starter. It took a while and with Gabriel gone, who was in his way? Troy Brown and Chad Jackson? . He became starter and was a no show until the playoffs. Even then his magic wore off in the AFCCG with 3 catches. Caldwell was very consistent in the second half of the season. Consistent throughout the playoffs, making the CLUTCH catches against the Chargers all until two drops. Keegs face it you know NOTHING about Jabar Gaffney. You didnt care about him until the playoffs and I highly doubt you ever watched him with the Texans. He is a decent reciever, nothing more, nothing less at least until I see him next year for a full season.

Gaffney dropped some balls. A perfect Tom Brady bomb bounced right off of Jabar's hands against the Texans. Reche dropped a rushed pass to the sidelines. Believe me if Gaffney dropped that long pass against the Colts you'd problably want to cut his ass too.

 

[Kdo5]

However, Maroney didn't have any huge boneheaded plays, Caldwell had 2

Well Keegs, considering Maroney is a running back, there arent many ways to make bone head plays if you can hold onto the ball. Maybe trying to dance around in the backfield, but even then people wouldnt hold it against him for months.

 

[Keegs]

Arguing that Dillon is generally a better playoff RB is ridiculous. Three games does not make a trend.

I just blasted your 3 game judgement out of the water by exposing the Maroney-Dillon stat lines

Short-term, knee-jerk reactions are a prescription for failure. Stay away from the stock market, kid.

no it's not ridiculous.
Dillon is a better playoff running back right now than Maroney.

You made a dogcrap comparison just like all the other dogcrap comparisons i've seen in this thread to Defend caldwell and his choke in Indianapolis.
Maybe if Maroney fumbled the ball twice inside the pats 20, then it would be a valid comparison. As of now, it is garbage.


thanks for the stock tips, Pops. don't worry, i would never buy a stock that crapped it's pants twice when it mattered most. I appreciate it anyways though.