Sorry, I missed that the 5-7 saints were 2-1 when we played them. You’re correct we’re 2-2 against teams with a winning record.
My point is really just that we haven’t played an offense that has more than 1 way to beat us since the Chargers, and we didn’t really stop the Chargers, so much as they beat themselves . Our defense has looked dominant against some seriously flawed offenses - which they should if they are great, so I’m not taking that away from them- but until they can stop an above average offense, I can’t project them to have a high ceiling.
Falcons without Patterson and Ridley, injured Mayfield and no Chubb/Hunt, Panthers that didn’t use McCaffrey for half a game (then he chewed us up), Jets backup QB (plus it’s the Jets)… Chargers were a few wide-open dropped passes from a win there too… so if you want to say we shoulda beat the cowboys… that’s a wash.
Anyway, it’s fun to think that Belichick taking over the D coincides with this stretch of dominance, but playing bad offenses also coincides.
I hope you’re right and it’s not just the competition, but we won’t find out this week facing a Titans team without Henry, Julio, or Brown. And I’m hoping this isn’t like 2019 where we started 8-0 with gawd “elite D” stats beating up junior varsity teams.
Until I see they can do it against a decent offense, I’m tempering my expectations on their ceiling.