Absolutely no way... anyone who thinks so is very ignorant of NFL history.
Maybe top five ACTIVE coaches.. but winning just one SB and being considered a "top 10 HC" is an insult to the great coaches in the history of the NFL, Curly Lambeau, Tom Landry, Joe Gibbs, George Halas, Chuck Noll, Bill Walsh, Vince Lombardi, Bill Belichick, and Paul Brown. There's then another handful that have won two, like Parcells and Shula, etc. that have to be considered.
i'd round out that top 10 you just listed with shula
2nd set of 10 would include guys like reid, parcells, vermeil, stram, johnson.....maybe even dungy? levy? it starts to get iffy when you try and quantify guys like shottenheimer, levy, dungy, allen, cowher, bud grant - different eras, all have positives and negatives
but i think a top 10 in some order would include BB, lambeau, halas, landry, noll, gibbs, walsh, lombardi, brown and shula - reid isn't close to that group yet, and probably not ever imho.......those are all legendary coaches.......reid might move himself to the upper tier of that next 10, but i don't see him ever cracking that top 10
you could make the case that guys like halas, lambeau & brown are foundational type guys, and are really from that "OG" era.......then you have guys like noll, lombardi, gibbs, shula, walsh from that "2nd Gen OG" era.......but the thing is, you can easily throw Lombardi into the original OG era and he stands up......you can put BB into either of those "OG" eras and he stacks up.......I can't put andy reid in with either of those groups
maybe when you just look at just the free agency era he'd be top 10? but all-time i think i'd forever have him in that 2nd tier......which still ain't bad
