Here are my grades for Brady for each of the first 4 games of last season. Do you agree with them?

[Taylor Nickels]

Week 1 (at Miami): D+ (because it was technically a tale of two halves, Brady played poorly, NOT very poorly, in that game, and whoever mentioned on Rotoworld that Brady was "sailing passes all afternoon" in that game was a complete idiot and clearly didn't watch the first half of that game at all).

Week 2 (at Minnesota): B- (I thought he played pretty well against an underrated Vikings defense, and more people might've recognized that had the Patriots not committed a jaw-dropping 7 penalties on offense, 3 of which were committed by Nate Solder)

Week 3 (vs. Oakland): C (mediocre)

Week 4 (at KC): F (although this was an entire team failure; the Patriots got outplayed and out-coached in practically

 

[Joey007]

I agree here for the most part. How come this is being brought up though?

 

[Taylor Nickels]

I agree here for the most part. How come this is being brought up though?

Because of that hack Mike Giardi who said that Brady needed to be evaluated after the KC debacle. He said that he had two very poor games (he actually had 1) and two merely average games (he actually had 1), and I called him out on his BS.

He ended up blocking me on Twitter. Good riddance. Ty Law called him out for saying such a stupid question to Belichick, so all's good.

 

[ViperGTS]

Tom Brady Super Bowl 4th Quarter Stats

Brady was a staggering 13-of-15 for 124 yards and two touchdowns with two lengthy scoring drives in the final eight minutes

http://thebiglead.com/2015/02/03/to...per-bowls-give-him-the-edge-over-joe-montana/

A+. Now leave troll.

 

[Taylor Nickels]

Tom Brady Super Bowl 4th Quarter Stats

Brady was a staggering 13-of-15 for 124 yards and two touchdowns with two lengthy scoring drives in the final eight minutes

http://thebiglead.com/2015/02/03/to...per-bowls-give-him-the-edge-over-joe-montana/

A+. Now leave troll.

I'm not a troll. I've been a Patriots fan for more than a decade now. I can give you my grades for the rest of that season as well (and they're extremely impressive grades).

 

[Bruins29]

So this thread is because of the difference between Brady playing poorly in the MIA game Giardi thinking it was very poor?

 

[Bruins29]

I can give you my grades for the rest of that season as well (and they're extremely impressive grades).

It must be in the form of a 10 page report

 

[Taylor Nickels]

So this thread is because of the difference between Brady playing poorly in the MIA game Giardi thinking it was very poor?

That, combined with the fact that he said Brady was merely average vs. Minnesota (he wasn't) and that he needed to be evaluated after 4 games (which was an idiotic statement).

 

[Joey007]

I just don't get the need to talk about this now. As BB would say "we're on to 2015."

 

[ViperGTS]

I just don't get the need to talk about this now. As BB would say "we're on to 2015."

This isn't what you think it is.

 

[Bruins29]

That, combined with the fact that he said Brady was merely average vs. Minnesota (he wasn't) and that he needed to be evaluated after 4 games (which was an idiotic statement).

SO you (a homer) gave Brady a B- for the Minny game, and some guy gave Brady a C for that game and you felt it was necessary to get all bent about it and drudge all this up a year later?

The whole team needed to be evaluated after those 4 games. They stunk.

 

[Bruins29]

I just don't get the need to talk about this now. As BB would say "we're on to 2015."

Exactly. Actually game one of 2015 is ancient history. I mean there might have been a good reason to bring up last years first 4 games. This certainly wasn't anywhere near a good reason.

The whole world was ****ting on Brady at that point, why single out this nitwit?

 

[Taylor Nickels]

SO you (a homer) gave Brady a B- for the Minny game, and some guy gave Brady a C for that game and you felt it was necessary to get all bent about it and drudge all this up a year later?

The whole team needed to be evaluated after those 4 games. They stunk.

Disagree about the whole team needing to be evaluated. It was really just certain units (i.e. OL, Gronkowski getting healthy, LaFell getting into the mix, Brady needing to play better, defense playing better--particularly against the run).

 

[Bruins29]

Disagree about the whole team needing to be evaluated. It was really just certain units (i.e. OL, Gronkowski getting healthy, LaFell getting into the mix, Brady needing to play better, defense playing better--particularly against the run).

ok, well here are your grades for your posting.