Ring 6
PatsFans.com Supporter
PatsFans.com Supporter
2021 Weekly Picks Winner
2022 Weekly Picks Winner
- Joined
- Sep 13, 2004
- Messages
- 63,761
- Reaction score
- 14,113
Re: Help needed to show Brady's superiority..
Stupid argument. First Manning has played longer. Second, Brady is destroying him in stats this year, 3rd, Manning has played in an offense that threw the ball all day, Brady palyed in an offense designed to win.
Here is two quick questions:
Does Peyton go to the HOF without Superbowl win? - Yes
Does Brady go to the HOF without Superbowl wins? - No
Brady is not even ranked in the top 50 of all - time, let alone to be considered as good as Peyton...
Heck - it will take him 4 more years to pass the great Kerry Collins..In 4 more years, Peyton moves from his current position of 10th to 3rd, behind Favre and Marino....
Currently:
Manny rank 10th
Brady rank 50+
Not sure aobut the arguement. They both are superbowl winners, but one is far superior statistically. Manning will probably own every record, and still be a superbowl winner. While Brady will probably fall in around 25th all-time statisically, with 3 superbowls. Not sure an arguement can be made for Brady. Because stats are a reflection of the player, while superbowls are a reflection of the Team.
Stupid argument. First Manning has played longer. Second, Brady is destroying him in stats this year, 3rd, Manning has played in an offense that threw the ball all day, Brady palyed in an offense designed to win.