The 2024 draft will always be a successful draft just because they drafted Drake Maye. Doesn't excuse the really bad picks that came in the rounds after, but Maye looks to be a potential top 5 QB, maybe top 3. When you get that in a draft, the draft is a success no matter how bad the draft is.
2024 was always going to be a weird draft. Most of the scouting was done under Belichick, Wolf hasn't installed his system and staff yet, and they selecting for Jerod Mayo who had no clue what he was looking for in terms of talent.
The first draft after a regime change frequently is a mix bag to a disaster no matter the team just because the new staff is left with the scouting and much of the staff of the previous regime. So even when the scouting is good, it really doesn't jibe with what the new staff is doing. For example, Belichick looked for different traits in players than Wolf or even Vrabel does. Their grading systems were completely different.
It was a little different with Wolf because he was here, but he was running the scouting the way Belichick wanted it and not with his system. Wolf wasn't able to have the tools he wanted or the grading system he wanted. I think we saw positive results of the new scouting system and staff last year and hopefully we will see it again this year with the 2026 free agency and draft.
The 2024 draft was a disaster past Maye. But it is time to move on. This team has a lot of good and young talent that they were able to amass in a very short period of time. We can cautiously assume that 2024 was an outlier and we will see better results moving forward. Too soon to tell with this rookie class, but last year's class was excellent.