Better year so far......Brees or Brady?

[VJCPatriot]

Brady, Rodgers, Brees. These guys are all champions. Proven winners. I'd love to see a matchup of either Brady vs Rodgers or Brady vs Brees in the Superbowl. There's gonna be a lot of points scored!

The stats, eh, they are alright, but pretty even. So I'll go with the guy who brings home with the Lombardi as tihs years best QB. Unless the guy is useless in actually helping win - ie see Big Ben's first championship win where the Steelers won despite him.

 

[The Brandon Five]

Brady, Rodgers, Brees. These guys are all champions. Proven winners. I'd love to see a matchup of either Brady vs Rodgers or Brady vs Brees in the Superbowl. There's gonna be a lot of points scored!

The stats, eh, they are alright, but pretty even. So I'll go with the guy who brings home with the Lombardi as tihs years best QB. Unless the guy is useless in actually helping win - ie see Big Ben's first championship win where the Steelers won despite him.

The zebras were the MVP's for the Steelers in that game.

 

[dex13]

only one stat matters....the QB with the better year will still be standing in February.

 

[MoLewisrocks]

only one stat matters....the QB with the better year will still be standing in February.

If it's one of these three, probably. But not absolutely. What if Smith or Cutler or Flacco or god forbid...Tebow is the last QB standing???

 

[robbomango]

If it's one of these three, probably. But not absolutely. What if Smith or Cutler or Flacco or god forbid...Tebow is the last QB standing???

1 SB win for those guys get's them trent dilfor status, never mentioned after that year.

repeating 2 plus get's them Bradshaw or Aikmen status, never mentioned in a GOAT conversation. just a great team convo

my guess

 

[Dufflebagz]

I can't compare till next monday. Brady still has to pad his stats against Indy too.

 

[NG Pats Fan]

You guys are kidding right? Brees has the best weapons I have ever seen. He gets to throw to a 6'6 freak # 1 Wide Receiver Marquis Colston..while Brady has nothing but 5'8 midget WRs to throw too. Not to mention Lance Moore, Devery Henderson, Robert Meachem...all easily faster than any WR we got on our team. Tight Ends Graham vs Gronk is a wash.

It amazes me the amazing stats Brady is able to put up with aging midget WRs. Give him a few young tall fast studs and he would break records again.

 

[Texxx]

Brees had a great game last night. He's right up there with Rogers and Brady, IMO. Whoever wins the SB is the best QB out of these three. !a, 1b, and 1c, with Brady as 1a based on toughness and experience in huge games. Can't wait until we play one.

I'll take the TD's over completions any day.

Again, the name of the game is to score.

Why would you say whomever wins the SB is automatically the best QB out of the three?? Football is to much of a team sport to state things that easily. For one, I'd say that the Saints have the better defense out of the Packers and the Patriots which gives Brees a nice advantage there. The teammates surrounding Brees and Rodgers have both won SB's before as well and know what it takes to get there unlike the teammates surrounding Tom Brady for the most part. The Pats probably have the worst defense out of the 3 as well, so to me Tom Brady is going to have to be a little bit more brilliant in the playoffs than what will be demanded of Rodgers and Brees, but we'll see. I think it will come down to circumstances and how each QB wills their team to win and how they overcome what is in front of them. If Rodgers wins the SB where his defense plays lights out and he has great protection to throw a ton of TD's and yards while Brady is getting hit left and right in a loss where the defense makes a ton of mistakes or other players on offense are fumbling the ball and stuff like that, then does that make Rodgers the better QB?? I don't think so. I think you've got to look at the entire picture.

 

[BradyFTW!]

If you put Brady on the Saints, I think that they would be improved. If you put Brees on the Patriots, I think that they would be worse. The reason being that the Saints have better WRs and RBs than the Pats do, and even at TE, the Pats are better overall but the Saints have Graham. There are just a ton of weapons in that offense.

On that basis, I'll take Brady, although it's not like you can go wrong with either of them. They're both clearly top-3 NFL QBs.

 

[aurakilla]

If it's one of these three, probably. But not absolutely. What if Smith or Cutler or Flacco or god forbid...Tebow is the last QB standing???

LETS SLOW DOWN HERE..........

IF ( Coming to America funny part - YouTube <-- Tebow in disguise ) Tebow wins a Superbowl this year I dont think I can watch football anymore if the NFL cant figure out how to stop a QB that throws 4 passes a game.

 

[Texxx]

Brady is doing more with less in my eyes and also has a defense that isn't as good as the NO defense.

Brady > Brees

 

[dex13]

Why would you say whomever wins the SB is automatically the best QB out of the three?? Football is to much of a team sport to state things that easily. For one, I'd say that the Saints have the better defense out of the Packers and the Patriots which gives Brees a nice advantage there. The teammates surrounding Brees and Rodgers have both won SB's before as well and know what it takes to get there unlike the teammates surrounding Tom Brady for the most part. The Pats probably have the worst defense out of the 3 as well, so to me Tom Brady is going to have to be a little bit more brilliant in the playoffs than what will be demanded of Rodgers and Brees, but we'll see. I think it will come down to circumstances and how each QB wills their team to win and how they overcome what is in front of them. If Rodgers wins the SB where his defense plays lights out and he has great protection to throw a ton of TD's and yards while Brady is getting hit left and right in a loss where the defense makes a ton of mistakes or other players on offense are fumbling the ball and stuff like that, then does that make Rodgers the better QB?? I don't think so. I think you've got to look at the entire picture.

LOL...you forgot to drink your daily kool-aid. How many times have BB and Brady driven home the point that winning the SB is what's it all about? Go back a few years to the Brady/Manning debate and what was the final argument that Brady was better...wasn't passing yards, wasn't passing TDs, or number of league MVPs, it was superbowl victories.

 

[nukin]

Brees has thrown it 40 times more, has only 60 more yards and one less touchdown... not to mention Brady has one less INT and a better QB rating.

 

[Bella*chick]

Brees has thrown it 40 times more, has only 60 more yards and one less touchdown... not to mention Brady has one less INT and a better QB rating.

Interesting stats. I really only pay attention to Brees when he has a national game whereas I follow Brady really closely, obviously. I wouldn't have guessed that about the interceptions.

 

[Luke Skywelker]

Let's not forget one thing in all of this - the elements factor. Give Tom a Dome to play in for 9(including Atlanta) games minimum and I'm sure some of his stats go up a bit.

 

[eric5280]

It's a virtual toss up but got to give Brady the nod. Ever so slightly superior stats against tougher defenses.

 

[MoneyFX]

Brady, for sure. Brees has two big targets in Colston and Graham who are physical specimens. He's also got speedsters in Henderson, Meachem and Moore. Brady has two talented tight ends, two small possession receivers and a former pro-bowler that is washed up.