- Joined
- Sep 16, 2004
- Messages
- 12,436
- Reaction score
- 13,148
Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.And it wasn't over after the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor!
Or when the Japanese started the Reichstag fire
Tom Coughlin might have something to say about that...Maybe second best and successful coach of an era entirely dominated by BB and the Pats. He is definitely in.
Tom Coughlin might have something to say about that...
7 11+ win seasons and a 12-7 playoff record w/ 2 SBs is not a mediocre career.Not really close. Two successful seasons with Giants dont wash away the mediocre rest.
7 11+ win seasons and a 12-7 playoff record w/ 2 SBs is not a mediocre career.
I guess Andy Reid's time management is like Mozart's paintings
Andy Reid after Sunday’s win: Not all of Mozart’s paintings were perfect
Edit: Mods, this was after Detroit. Not Colts.
I'll always take the coach which has multiple seasons of double-digit wins and A Super Bowl title. Especially one that has done it twice.Coughlin is barely over 0.5 as a coach. Reid over 60% with the same amount of games and they shared a division for a long time.
One has consistently developed as times and offenses moved forward the other stuck to his -- relatively successful -- defensive blueprint.
Yeah, Reid sucks at time management which most probably cost him a couple titles.
I respect Reid more.
I'll always take the coach which has multiple seasons of double-digit wins and A Super Bowl title. Especially one that has done it twice.
Andy Reid thought he was playing in the KFC Championship game last year, not AFC Championship...
So would I. Coughlin's body of work is very good.I'd rather look at their entire body of work and not just the postseason.
I also completely disagree that Eli is a HoF QB. I couldn't care less if he won two titles his entire body of work is more telling then those two outliers.
I'll always take the coach which has multiple seasons of double-digit wins and A Super Bowl title. Especially one that has done it twice.
Reid hasn't had great Qbs either.And with Eli as his QB.