I liked that WEEI finally changed it up and brought in a homer to counter the contrarians of Felger and Mazz rather than more clones of Felger and Mazz like they did prior, but Fitzy was just the wrong guy. Fitzy just isn’t a compelling enough radio. Most homers are only good in smaller doses - see Fred Smerlas.
Boston sports radio sucks now, but WEEI has put on a master class of sports radio suckitude over the last decade or so. They just have no clue how to counter program the Sports Hub. It shouldn’t be that hard since Felger and Mazz’s act has gotten stale and morning and midday shows aren’t exactly power houses. And WEEI still has some of the better media guests under contract.
Speaking of the latter, I think where WEEI drops the ball is having their media guests do short segments. Most of them aren’t on the air more than 5-10 minutes at a time. Meanwhile the Sports Hub have their media guests like Albert Breer or Greg Bedard on for entire hours or more. Even if you don’t like these media guests, it at least keeps the shows fresher by giving different perspectives and bring new information to the discussions rather than three hours every day rehashing the same discussions and callers. The way WEEI has guests, it can feel canned and forced because it is clear they have a script of questions.
I didn’t hate Fitzy and Hart, I do subscribe to their show as a podcast, but I rarely listen to their show. I only do it if they have a topic I want to listen to or I have nothing else I want to listen to.