I haven’t been on the board much. If people are still stanning for Mac they’re ****ing idiots. The guy was exactly what the scouting reports said, a solid game manager who can play the position competently but won’t win games by making big plays. In other words, a perfect quarterback for the Belichick-Parcells era of football that ended in the early 90s. In the modern game, an inevitable disappointment whose limitations relegate him to fringe starter or backup.
Not a knock on him or the pick. 5th QB taken in the draft. 15th overall. The limitations were well known. Obviously not every QB is an all pro. Most are busts, even in the first round. C’est la vie.
Ironically I remember a thread about how Mac never hit the big deep dagger pass and everyone blamed the WRs. It took Maye two quarters to throw a ridiculous dime that created separation.
I’d much rather have a high ceiling QB like Maye. If he fails, he fails. It’s worth the pick and the time / effort for a guy with his attributes and skills. Do we want to win championships or Andy Dalton are way to proud mediocrity? Well, to win, you need an absolute monster of a QB, not a steady hand. The risk here is worth it.
We can’t really be assessing his performance on interceptions right now. Who the **** cares? First we want to see that he can make elite plays. All the other stuff with the timing, decision making, pocket movement is well down the line of checkpoint stuff. If anyone is disappointed in today’s performance, they’re truly clueless. Josh Allen just went 9/30 against that defense, the pressure was intense all game, and Maye was playing from behind, with a C and LT who moonlight as security guards at Wal Mart. Remarkable debut performance.