I watched a lot of pac10 games last year- Penix was easily the best qb in that conference. Yes, he had wrs, but his ol was not great. Williams wasn't great. He rode a great 2022 season to that #1 pick.
But dude has zero leadership ability.
He's very small for a qb. His intermediate throws are very good but his deep ball is lacking.
Both Maye and Daniels have off the chart intangibles, unlike Caleb. Both have better deep balls. Both are tougher.
Both are way less self-absorbed.
I've never been a guy who wants someone to fail just because I was down on them in the draft.
I've never understood that mentality. I want all these guys to succeed, unless they play for a rival or the Jete.
I'd love to see Caleb turn into an elite qb.
I just don't think he will. He will be a decent qb but not on Maye's level.
And I'd bet my left nut Daniels will have a better career.( but those Tyquan Thornton legs scare the **** out of me)