It's an internet message board, it's made for opinion and speculation. A guy with Maye's size, skill set, age, experience etc, generally become great QB's so yeah, make sense to talk like that. Someone like Bryce Young almost never succeeds historically so we should just ignore all the evidence and just wait until it plays out to say these things? Booorinng!.
Why wait until these guys prove it to speculate and give an opinion, it would make the board kind of dull in the off season to just talk about what is and what just happened.
It also allows you a chance to gloat later or be bashed as an idiot for a bad take, that's some good times!