Let me introduce you to Peyton Manning, Joe Montana, and Brett Favre.
Why is it so difficult for people to understand that it was good for both to move on?
Devil’s advocate.
Peyton Manning was damaged goods and the greatest QB prospect since him was there for the taking to set them up for the future.
Brett Farve had a stud in Aaron Rodgers behind him. Farve had been playing games forever with whether he would retire. He wasn’t committed. Finally they said, “no we have this really talented guy who wants to play the next 10 years, we aren’t losing him because you aren’t sure”
Montana was badly injured for two seasons and Steve Young was winning MVP’s. It was a no brainer. They had an elite guy right there.
….The Patriots let Brady walk for….. Stidham… so they could desperately sign Cam Newton who was washed…. Hoyer…. Oh wait they got rid of him so they could hope and pray someone like Mac fell to them to see if someday he could be an elite QB. There was no other apparent guy. Those teams had a reasonable future mapped out and their QB’s were compromised in some way. Brady didn’t have Manning or Montana’s devastating injuries, and he wasn’t jerking his team around with lack of commitment to playing like Farve. He was an all time great who could still play that wanted to be here.
The team decided their system was too important to give the top player in the leagues history a multi year contract because they were too afraid that they would be one year too late if he declined mid contract and they’d have to grit their teeth for a season.
If they had some other guy, okay Tom Brady sorry but the future is now. They didn’t. They just didn’t want to take the potential downside of being Tom Brady’s endgame plan. The Bucs assumed that risk. Hence, they got to be the team he retired from and who got the lionshare of the celebration.
The sad thing is 10 years from now with perspective I think most people will realize that sacrificing one even two rough years would have been nothing in comparison to how special it would be for the greatest NFL player ever to retire as a Patriot. That moment was taken from us for no real reason besides the system was too important to see the big picture.