- Joined
- Dec 18, 2004
- Messages
- 12,754
- Reaction score
- 22,824
Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.
You can make a case for keeping Newton as a placeholder, until Mac is ready to start.
On the other hand I was already having trouble making a case for retaining N'Keal, and that was before this evening's laughable commentary from his agent.
You don’t have a choice for “Both”…..so I’ll say Both!!!)If you had a choice between keeping Cam or Harry...
While I think Cam will indeed be on the roster, I’ll play devil’s advocate.Weird false dichotomy to present considering they aren't fighting for a single spot and we could easily keep both or neither. Cam sucks but he's still a top 2 QB on this roster so it would be pretty stupid to get rid of him. Harry has been on his way out since free agency.
Sure, if any of those were true, it would give Cam a chance of not making the cut. I just don't think any of those things are actually the case and I'm not sure you do either.While I think Cam will indeed be on the roster, I’ll play devil’s advocate.
the reasons you might dump Cam :
*he only wants to be a starter and Jones is chosen over him
*you figure you’re all in w Jones and even if he needs replacing (for whatever reason) you decide you’re better off just going with Stidham or Hoyer
*you see that because of Cam’s stature and popularity that the only way the team moves forward is off Cam isn’t in the locker to take over.
*big personality who isn’t on the field is never to the advantage of a BB run team.
Agreeing. Cam likely makes the team & has a good chance of starting.Sure, if any of those were true, it would give Cam a chance of not making the cut. I just don't think any of those things are actually the case and I'm not sure you do either.
Cam seems like a legitimately good teammate, and potential reasons #1, 3, 4 boil down to the idea that he isn't. #2 is based on the delusional idea that Hoyer is better than anyone.
Maybe if Stidham actually starts showing something.
If Mac is kicking ass, the Cam situation will be a must-watch.Agreeing. Cam likely makes the team & has a good chance of starting.
But the league is full of egomaniacs. I don’t think you want to keep Cam if he isn’t your starter.