- Joined
- Jul 11, 2005
- Messages
- 15,532
- Reaction score
- 27,569
if I could interject a thought here. I think you are having an apples to oranges argument here. The way I'm reading it is that you think DT is the better option over JG because past history tells us we never know if or when Gordon will be there. While the other guy is just comparing the WR's athletically.fair enough
I don't think that Thomas is even in the same category as the players you name. There are Edelman, Thomas and Gordon. When available, the rest are far behind in any depth chart (by the way, I would include Harry).
Are you really saying that you would cut Thomas to keep any of the players below?
I suppose if we were betting the field (the players you name) vs Thomas with regard to season long production, it could be close, but only because of the possibility that Thomas weren't healthy.
So here's my question to you. Assuming that when Gordon returns, he will be there the rest of the season, which WR would you rather have. (and I know that is a HUGE assumption, but bear with me)