So Who's The Second Best Quarterback Of All Time ?

[Pat the Pats Fan]

Unitas,,,,, the other QB that won a championship game in OT, and not on a neutral site, it was in NY

 

[PatsBoy12]

Its Joe Cool.

<end>

Yup. By the length of a football field, I'd like to add.

 

[JMC00]

and Marino has none.

Which in returns hurts that ******* Shula..

Had one of the best QBs of all time and got to the SB 1 time in 12-13 years with him... 6-7 with Marino in the playoffs.

 

[Dorito Dink]

Well according to one of facebook "friends," who is a diehard packers fan, it looks like Brady is still number 2 and Rodgers is #1. People like this clearly have a disease. The tears are delicious though!

 

[Deus Irae]

Well according to one of facebook "friends," who is a diehard packers fan, it looks like Brady is still number 2 and Rodgers is #1. People like this clearly have a disease. The tears are delicious though!

I'll always love that sort of reasoning. Let's apply it:

Jeff George is the most talented quarterback to ever play the game. Therefore, even though he did nothing in the NFL, Jeff George is the all time greatest.

 

[RelocatedPatFan]

Well according to one of facebook "friends," who is a diehard packers fan, it looks like Brady is still number 2 and Rodgers is #1. People like this clearly have a disease. The tears are delicious though!

What that fan fails to realize is how 1 person makes the players around them better. They are focusing on the aspect where Rodgers is better than Brady without considering all that it takes for a quarterback to succeed. It's not 1-2 attributes, it takes all of them together.

To quote Rocky (I) a bit. Aaron Rodgers quarterbacks great, but Brady is a great quarterback.

i.e. Rodgers is the more physically gifted QB. TB is the better QB overall.

 

[Harrious]

You can argue Joe Montana as the best ever. I'd put him behind Brady. He was clutch and had lots of success. But please don't argue 4-0 vs 5-2. Failing to make the Super Bowl is not better than losing in the Super Bowl. But of course I'm preaching to the choir.