My point was that it isn't now but may be seen as such lets say 10 years from now. What other fanbases and the media (NFL films, plus broadcast networks for example) across the league remember as a dynasty's signature moment kind of form these thing just as much as the original fanbase and franchise itself to be honest. As an example, The Giants have already had a long and storied NFL Championship, and Super Bowl winning history before Super Bowl 42, but the Tyree catch has (unfortunately for us) probably replaced any other play in Giant history as the most iconic. The Vinatieri kicks are still commonly played in league wide montages so the original post was only speculative in the first place...
Well, y'all know how much I loathe the Giants, but they consistently do things on and off the field that put themselves underneath the Ravens as the absolute worst, most unrootable franchise in, perhaps, all of sports. It just gets worse and worse.
So here they are, they actually weren't bad back in the day, with more than one iconic moment with Y.A. Tittle, for example. The only thing he couldn't do is win a title there, but man, he was everything Peyton Manning wasn't. The guy is really a national hero, and belongs in the conversation about the G.O.A.T.
So the Tyree catch is big for them (um, Seymour was held) but it's nothing compared to the performance of Burress against the Packers the game before, or the '86 champions, or really, the '56 champs.
Bottom line, I don't care about the Giants.
I do care, a lot, about us, the Pats, and no matter what they're saying over there, our history and identity
are being ignored.