Interesting Brady Vs. Manning debate.

[Palm Beach Pats Fan]

mediums can be the plural of medium, but it would be two people like this:

 

[E1Downey]

Not sure what's so interesting about that debate. In fact, anyone who's still thinks that it is one is just in denial, at this point. Brady is an objectively superior quarterback. People who think otherwise apparently haven't realized that there are better measures of a QB's skills than career passing yards and TDs (and by extension must think that Brett Favre is the greatest QB of all time).

To note, Brady's last 4 seasons have been:
2007: A historically good season, one of the best of all-time. Consensus MVP, better than any season that Manning has ever put together.
2008: lost to injury
2009: recovery year, still did exceptionally well against a historically difficult defensive schedule (Football Outsiders ranked him as having the #1 overall defense-adjusted QB season).
2010: A historically good season, one of the best of all-time. Only unanimous MVP in league history, better than any season that Manning has ever put together.

If a guy wins 2 MVPs in 3 years, setting major all-time records both times, both times for the winningest team in the league, then he is probably the best at his position. If pretty much every efficiency statistic in the books backs up the notion that he is the best, then he definitely is.

Not that I disagree or anything with your point but that might be two mvps in 4 years not 3

 

[BradyFTW!]

Not that I disagree or anything with your point but that might be two mvps in 4 years not 3

Of the last 3 years that he has played, he's won 2 MVPs.

 

[PatsFanInVa]

I find gaming funny. It's not like there's a whole real world out there to be explored.

Good to see Brady vs Manning transgresses all mediums.

I can't let people be bigger douches than me, so I'll point out that what you have said here is that Brady vs. Manning has sinned against all necromancers.

I think the word you wanted in this case was transcends.

Also, in my "real" fantasy drafts, Brady was going in the first round after the top 3 running backs, and before the "official" best QB, Aaron Rodgers. I mock drafted a few times to get ready, same story. And yes, I have no life.

Manning? Low second, early third.

QED, for now. But hey, no way to know until the games - that's why we play the actual fantasy season.

 

[E1Downey]

Of the last 3 years that he has played, he's won 2 MVPs.

Touché, who knows what 2008 could have been....

 

[Joker]

QED?????

I HATE that cliche.....and my name is HEDLEY!...

 

[PatsFanInVa]

Quidquid latine dictum sit, altum sonatur, as they say.

 

[lurker1965]

Can't agree. I hate stupid people regardless of the suck factor. Obviously there is a good amount of crossover between both groups, but those that suck are not always stupid and visa versa. Hope that helps.

You either hate or love politics.
Oh, this is not an opening for a political discussion. BTW, for the record, Demicans and Republicrats, a pox on both your houses and you fiends distract from football.

 

[Ice_Ice_Brady]

WOW perfect way to put this debate into perspective. I'd like to quote you on this if you don't mind of course.

Go right ahead.