Of course Boise could compete in the SEC. I have no doubt. People are putting too much emphasis on conference affiliation.
Did you all see UConn totally dominate Steve Spurrier's South Carolina team? USC is a SEC team, right?
IMO, it literally means nothing to be just another team in a power conference. You need to get to the top of the conference to see the domination. Florida and Alabama are it. Yes, they would destroy Boise State. if you think Boise had a tough time with TCU's defense, they would be near blanked by Alabama.
The same goes for the Big 12. Texas got to see what a real defense plays like last night. Week in and week out, Texas plays defenses that offer the resistance of fleas!! I'm not saying they are not one of the top 3 teams in the nation, they definitely are, but go somewhere else if you're trying to convince me that I should respect the rest of the Big 12. I don't. I respect the DT from Nebraska, and after that I can't tell a difference between the Big 12 and Big East. Same thing with the Pac10 and the Big10 outside of Ohio State who is not being coached well at this point (poor QB Pryor looks lost).
I watch the Fiesta Bowl and I was disappointed in Boise's play, particularly in the heralded Boise QB who didn't look like he was very accurate or had much of an arm. I credit the coach for getting them to play hard, and he also has guts and an imagination. But Boise left plays all over the field against a vaunted TCU defense. Wide open guys, and the ball could not get there, and there were drops. That did not look like a top offense to me. I would take Cincy's offense over Boise's any day of the week, and we saw how Florida humiliated Cincy.
In short, you have 3 top teams this year, then about 10-12 others who performed equally but in truth could easily lose to teams ranked 15-35.
Lots of parity, and 3 dominating teams, 3 teams who also finish on top of the recruiting rankings regularly with USC.
USC, Texas, Bama, Florida.
Top recruiting classes year after year. Sometimes LSU slips in there and Ohio State.