- Joined
- Oct 10, 2006
- Messages
- 76,883
- Reaction score
- 66,866
Yes. You are pointing to the still alive, old smokers. I've suscribed to the Mel Kiper guides for 20 years now ( yes I'm an old timer, 43. ) I used to subscribe to Joel Buschbaum's ( close Belichick friend ), for years, before he died. I can remember when you used to order the Kiper guides by phone and Mel would answer the phone at his house and take your order. And of course I have every ProFootball Weekly and Patriots football weekly, just to name a few.
I have been through the Pro Football Focus data, and it is my opinion, that as a whole, it is the best I have ever seen.
From the PFF site itself:
My firm belief is that we are between 98-100% accurate in terms of statistics and Player Participation 80-90% accurate in terms of grading.
ProFootballFocus.com - About
Even the site itself claims a 10%-20% error rate in grading. The reality is that PFF is fine for data, although it needs to be double checked whenever possible, but it's absolutely horrible when it comes to formula/grading.
Last edited: