- Joined
- Jan 27, 2008
- Messages
- 5,712
- Reaction score
- 4,539
That 22 QB rating kind of sticks out, though.
Take your logic elsewhere
:bricks:
Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.That 22 QB rating kind of sticks out, though.
Correction
Drew Brees is on top
I respect the analysts that said Brees is now elite with Brady and Manning.
I still think Manning is a better overall QB than Tom Brady but it's a close race. In terms of success though, it's ludicrous to consider anyone but Tom Brady though.
That 22 QB rating kind of sticks out, though.
You probably only still think Manning is the better overall QB because you would look foolish to back down from your point now. IMO, I think you went with the flavor of the month as well. Tell me, did you think that Manning was the better overall QB in 2007 when Brady finally got some weapons and lit up the league to the tune of 50 TD's and 8 INT's? You probably did, right?
I don't base my opinions on one season so yes, I thought it was still Manning.
I have yet to see Brady play a season outside of '07 where he is 100% mentally and physically and has a decent supporting cast. If he gets some people that can catch and has another outstanding year (not 2007 stats but impressive) I might back off of Manning.
Brady's been better than Manning since long before '07, and his adjusted numbers (home/home and Indoors/Indoors) are better than Manning's despite having generally had a far lesser receiving corps and a lesser running game for most of his career.
Fine
You've convinced me
thank you for showing me the light
You're the one who tried pulling the "stats" argument.
I wasn't upset
I don't want Manning to be better it was just an opinion
Take your logic elsewhere
:bricks: