Which drop off is more significant?

[TheGodInAGreyHoodie]

The loss of which player hurts the NEP offense more.

Losing Tom Brady and replacing him with Matt Cassell.

Or Losing Randy Moss and replacing him with Brandon Tate.

 

[TriplecHamp]

Its because of the season Brady was coming off of and the level he was playing at. If it was 2009 Brady vs 2008 Cassel, Id go with Moss>Tate

 

[Coach42]

Its close but Tate was highly regarded before his injuries. Cassel carried water for years.

 

[voluntarysaftey]

the brady to cassel dropoff was 5 games. (i know thats simplifying it a bit, but the 08 team wasn't much different than the 07 team)
I dont thin moss to tate will be a 5 game difference.