The Brady to Brown against Miami in 2003 was my favorite regular season moment, with Bledsoe to Coates in the mix and beating the Chargers this year 38-14 in week 2, because that's when I said "we might have something special."
Post-season, the kick to beat the Rams/Ty Law's INT in that game, and beating the Colts in 2005/2004 season, divisionals with a series of JAGs playing in the secondary against the mighty Colts, and they scored 3 points. The snow bowl tying FG was awesome, but made much bigger by what happened the next 2 weeks. But it has to be in the discussion.