PatsFans.com Menu
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans
PatsFans.com - The Hub For New England Patriots Fans

Poll: best Patriots moment

Next Opp: TBD
THE HUB FOR PATRIOTS FANS SINCE 2000

CURRENT POPULAR DISCUSSIONS:
What is our plan for ILB?
Posted By: JayNM
May 02, 2026 at 1:12 am
Total Replies: 154

# Of Users:38
mgteichcaptain stoneGumbyWater BoystinkypeteZumaDaBruinzp8rytsRxJock1120jmt57PatsFan2
Is Mike’s job security in any danger now? (Vrabel Allegedly Caught K...
Posted By: Joey007
May 02, 2026 at 1:04 am
Total Replies: 705

# Of Users:136
IanmgteichVrabelMayeWinThe Gr8estDarrylSSean Pa PatriotIcyPatriotCrazy Patriot GuybresnaMrTibbstuckeverlasting
TODAY'S MOST REACTED POSTS:
Huckleberry1What is our plan for ILB?
1 Reactions
04/30 at 6:16 pm

By: Huckleberry1

ClonameryDraft Rumours 2026
1 Reactions
05/01 at 1:44 pm

By: Clonamery

TODAY'S TOP POSTERS:#
n1997y4 posts
captain stone4 posts
mayoclinic2 posts
ctpatsfan771 posts
patfanken1 posts
 

Which of these was the all time best Patriots moment? Or was it some other?

  • Jets Butt Fumble

    Votes: 3 2.6%
  • Super Bowl LI Falcons 28-3 overtime comeback

    Votes: 38 33.3%
  • Super Bowl XXXVI Brady’s first vs Greatest Show on Turf

    Votes: 43 37.7%
  • Super Bowl XLIX “Go, Malcolm! Go!”

    Votes: 29 25.4%
  • Super Bowl LIII shutdown the Rams 13-3

    Votes: 1 0.9%

  • Total voters
    114
Status
Not open for further replies.
Of our Championships?
Ahhh... yeah, it isn't happening for me.
 
I'm getting less and less into this Website right now, it's because the load was blown, now it's just beating each other up...I've done it, and it's not who I want to be.
Embarrassing is a fkn low budget way of saying I'm Sorry guys, but I'm Sorry.
You guys are my crew, and sometimes I disagree(some BEYOND RIDICULOUS), and I do/say things I regret.
NOT ALL

We ALL want the SAME THING, PATS TO BE RELEVANT.
 
Malcolm Butler pick to seal it. Something about the drama of that game, the clutch nature of that play, and the look on Sherman’s face was pure ecstasy.

28-3 close second.

36 was awesome too but winning on a FG somehow just wasn’t quite as exciting.
 
Malcolm Butler pick to seal it. Something about the drama of that game, the clutch nature of that play, and the look on Sherman’s face was pure ecstasy.

28-3 close second.

36 was awesome too but winning on a FG somehow just wasn’t quite as exciting.

I TOTALLY forgot about the look on that dbags face. How about......"YOU MAD BRO??!??"... I could have sworn I saw tears in one of the pics of him right after that play.. Honestly I think he was a decent player but his loud obnoxious mouth got in the way of his career being better than it could have been. I don't think we ever heard another "You mad?" out of his mouth since. Kudos to Brady for breaking this dude....
 
**** Him, Sherman was a great player, but TB12 made his life miserable...
"****, wtf was that"
 
Malcolm Butler pick to seal it. Something about the drama of that game, the clutch nature of that play, and the look on Sherman’s face was pure ecstasy.

28-3 close second.

36 was awesome too but winning on a FG somehow just wasn’t quite as exciting.
Kind of crazy to think 36 was the first walk off in SB history and the other 8 SBs were equally or even more climatic.
 
Jan 12, 1986. Beating the Phins and Don Shula in the AFC Championship game in Miami by running the ball down their throats, dominating time of possession, and picking off crybaby Marino two times.

No one had the Patriots winning that game.
 
Malcolm Butler pick to seal it. Something about the drama of that game, the clutch nature of that play, and the look on Sherman’s face was pure ecstasy.

28-3 close second.

36 was awesome too but winning on a FG somehow just wasn’t quite as exciting.
haha, yes, the look on Sherman's face was priceless!
 
You said moments and then put entire games.

As far as moments go:

I started with.

Brady spiking the ball just before Vinatieri's kick. There's the moment of wholly **** what did that kid just do. Combined with confidence that Vinatieri wouldn't miss after having seen those snow kicks.

Then of course there is the moment it went thru the uprights.

I also considered the OT coin toss vs ATL, White's game sealing run, or Edelman's catch because of the significance of getting our own Catch.

But ultimately I think it's the greatest moment in football history. The change of fates for 2 franchises flipped the moment Butler intercepted Russ.
There’s very few other moments that could even rank against it if we measure by long term significance.

The catch and the tuck rule might be the only other two.
 
There’s very few other moments that could even rank against it if we measure by long term significance.

The catch and the tuck rule might be the only other two.
It does kind of stand alone. We've had so many and things can resonate with individuals differently so if someone picked Vinatieri's game winner vs Rams or something else then great but Butler's INT may be the greatest moment in NFL history nevermind just team history.

PS: we're totally spoiled in this department.
 
If we're talking moment, it's either AV kick to beat the Rams or the Butler Interception - both won SBs and are iconic in New England and US sports lore. (I chose Butler since it's just an incredible play)

but 28-3 really encompasses everything great about the TB/BB Patriots - it all came together for the best comeback in sports history.

I agree with this. Moments and games are different categories. For moments the Vinatieri kick to beat the Rams, and the Butler interception are tied, but I have to give the tiebreaker to the Butler interception, because it took away certain victory and gave certain victory at the same time.

For game’s it’s even harder, as the 1st Lombardi against the Rams was surreal, the win over Seattle was against a great defense, and 28-3 the greatest comeback of All Time. The tiebreaker for me was the Rams Super Bowl, because it was so improbable, and because it fulfilled Ricky Proehl’s in game declaration, “ Tonight a Dynasty is born.”
 
I voted Butler because imo it was an inflection point for the dynasty. We were on the verge of going 3-3 with Brady/Belichick, it was going to be the third Super Bowl where a late game circus catch cost them, Deflategate just happened and a SB loss would have been a total moral killer for everyone. It got Brady a 4th ring, which was the magic Joe Montana number. It capped off the "the Patriots aren't good anymore" turn around. It prevented us going over a decade without SB wins, and it kicked off the real second wind of the franchise.

Winning the first was the only thing comparable in terms of overall impact.

If you remove out all the context and just go with how big a moment was that day, it's probably 28-3.
 
I voted Butler because imo it was an inflection point for the dynasty. We were on the verge of going 3-3 with Brady/Belichick, it was going to be the third Super Bowl where a late game circus catch cost them, Deflategate just happened and a SB loss would have been a total moral killer for everyone. It got Brady a 4th ring, which was the magic Joe Montana number. It capped off the "the Patriots aren't good anymore" turn around. It prevented us going over a decade without SB wins, and it kicked off the real second wind of the franchise.

Winning the first was the only thing comparable in terms of overall impact.

If you remove out all the context and just go with how big a moment was that day, it's probably 28-3.
That INT was crucial. Had he dropped it and the Seahawks scored on another play, we would’ve seen a lot of finger pointing within the locker room and among the media leading to a potential early divorce berween Tom and Bill
 
Malcolm Butler pick to seal it. Something about the drama of that game, the clutch nature of that play, and the look on Sherman’s face was pure ecstasy.

28-3 close second.

36 was awesome too but winning on a FG somehow just wasn’t quite as exciting.
The look on Sherman’s face is part of that moment.

The look on both Blanks’ faces is almost as good, especially in the context of Arthur earlier busting out his dance moves prematurely.

 
But DAMN!!! That was fun.

That was just the beginning of the humiliating pantsing of the Rats on national TV on Thanksgiving evening.

Rex Ryan - “Un-bleeping believable.”

It was actually the middle play of a three TD disaster for the Jest. Vereen had a super long TD right before the butt fumble series, and of course, Edelman on the ensuing kickoff.

Chef's kiss...
 
The look on Sherman’s face is part of that moment.

The look on both Blanks’ faces is almost as good, especially in the context of Arthur earlier busting out his dance moves prematurely.


Especially for his role in Defamegate...this was glorious.
 
It was actually the middle play of a three TD disaster for the Jest. Vereen had a super long TD right before the butt fumble series, and of course, Edelman on the ensuing kickoff.

Chef's kiss...

You know there were a few times I honestly felt bad for Bills fans when they'd get themselves all riled up that 'this' was the year they'd dethrone the king and then Brady & Co would just de-pant them again and again and again...

Curiously that never happened with the Jete, I enjoyed every last ounce of misery they endured. The Jete just couldn't be curb stomped enough for me.
 
You know there were a few times I honestly felt bad for Bills fans when they'd get themselves all riled up that 'this' was the year they'd dethrone the king and then Brady & Co would just de-pant them again and again and again...

Curiously that never happened with the Jete, I enjoyed every last ounce of misery they endured. The Jete just couldn't be curb stomped enough for me.

Still true for me to this day as well. I can't explain it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
MORSE: Clearing the Notebook from the Patriots Draft
What Does An Early Look At The Patriots’ 53-Man Roster Prediction Look Like?
MORSE: Final Patriots Draft Analysis
Patriots News 04-26, Meet The Patriots’ 2026 Draft Class
MORSE: Patriots Day Three of NFL Draft, UDFA Signings
Patriots Grab A Big Offensive Tackle in Round Six On Saturday
Patriots Take a CB With Their First Pick on Day 3
Wolf Cites ‘Untapped Potential’ After Patriots Select Notre Dame Tight End Raridon
Patriots Trade-Up Landed Them a Defensive Menace in Jacas
TRANSCRIPT: Eliot Wolf Night Two Press Conference 4/24
Back
Top