- Joined
- Dec 22, 2005
- Messages
- 13,685
- Reaction score
- 16,169
Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.
Who did not vote for Gronk and Edelman?
Good poll. I love a Mount Rushmore conversation. Concept invented by Bill Simmons I believe.
I also contend that the Mount Rushmore of American sports history is now Ruth, Ali, Jordan, and Brady.
Johnny U is what Brady would have been without the last 3 titles- early success that petered out. Unitas was a great QB. Bart Starr was a champion.
I’ve been thinking a lot about the amount Rushmore of QBs, as there will be 4 QB slots for 100th anniversary team. I’ve been studying up a lot on older eras and quarterbacks accomplishments, including stats relative to era. Here is what I have:
Tom Brady
Otto Graham
Joe Montana
Johnny Unitas / Bart Starr
Can’t decide which one between Unitas and Starr, as it is so close; contrary to popular opinion, Starr had great stats for his era and wasn’t just carried by his team. Unitas transformed the position, but Earl Morrall won an MVP coming in as his backup for a year (so Unitas also has a very talented cast around him.)
You almost need to have Unitas on the list, but there’s no way that Brady, Montana, or Graham can get bumped, and Starr is pretty much deserving in every way. Starr was a lot like Brady, very clutch and someone who always came through with the game on the line. Graham is the only QB who you can truly argue GOAT over Brady if you count his AAFL years, roughly half his career. His dominance approaches Ruthian levels, but it’s pre-expansion era without multiple elimination games to win a championship.
If the voters put Manning on, it will be a travesty. Historically, he’s a 10-15 all-time QB who won MVP more times than he should have. It’s funny reading about these quarterbacks...many of them called their own plays. Manning was truly a media created illusion. I’m 1000% convinced that there’s at least 20 QBs throughout history that would consistently outperform him in elimination games. He wasn’t even “the smartest” QB of his era.
Another good one. I agree the fourth slot after Graham, Brady and Montana is the hardest. I don’t know enough about those guys to have a definitive opinion.
Manning would be on the Regular Season Mount Rushmore without a doubt!
Lol...that is funny.
In reality, though, he is really overrated as a regular season QB too. You look at his supporting cast and high INT rate for his era compared to his elite competitors, extremely weak division, most of his career played in dome and warm weather. Maybe top 5-10 regular season QB all-time. Brady, Montana, Graham, Unitas, and Starr were just flat out better than the phony audible calling drama queen. Even post-2000, is he really clearly better than Brees or Rodgers?