They also didn't have Chris Jones, a far superior offensive line or defense nearly as good as later teams... but QB is the only difference. Sounds legit.
The defenses were much better? What world? Here’s the point per drive from years 13-17 by rank. 5,7,7,8,21. This resulted in 1-4 in playoffs games. Here’s from 18-22 with mahomes. 28,12,13,19, 21st. Might want to brush up on the facts before making that bold of a claim
So what you're saying is KC's playoff record prior to Mahomes arrival falls entirely on Alex Smith, but the Patriots record from 2005-2013 doesn't fall on Brady? Makes sense... QB's make all the difference unless a superior QB in your mind fails... at that point it's somebody else's fault.
I didn’t say it was all of anybody’s anything. Smith wasn’t good enough to elevate the chiefs teams consistently. I’m sure there’s an alternate universe out there where he and Reid ran into a ring. Not in earth though
I also meant Brady’s “pay” not “play”- He was certainly not perfect every week.
When Mahomes got hurt in 2019 Reid went 2-1 with Matt Moore, who threw 4 TD's/zero INT's and had 102.1 QB Rating. He won with Alex Smith, Mike Vick post jail and Donovan McNabb. Reid can make offense out of anything, even if Mahomes is superior to all these guys.
Reid is a great coach, I’ll say it again. Your definition of winning seems to be stretching awfully far now though. He won Super Bowls with Mahomes, he’s dominated with him, built a dynasty with him. He was good with the others.
If Mahomes offensive line or defense collapses due to injury... the Chiefs won't win. This isn't a Disney movie.
But they’ll always be competitive, just like the patriots were with Brady. Through roster turnover, bad drafts, injuries and cap casualties…they’ll always be competitive as long as Mahomes is there
Win Super Bowls... the Pats with Brady didn't win a Super Bowl with Brady for a decade straight. Make up your mind... it's either magical unicorn QB's or it's not. I think your take is garbage and it comes down to complete team, history supports this completely.
You are free to disagree. I have never said the rest of his team didnt matter, just that he is the piece the success revolves around
Yet still good. The Chiefs wouldn't win crap without Chris Jones either.
How could they ever win without a mediocre defense? Its basically all hes anchored since hes joined the league. Meanwhile, we can compare it to the offenses?
Their entire offense was built around an RPO QB and a drop back passer was forced into the lineup. The Eagles recognized this and fixed it by bringing Marcus Mariota in as a backup this offseason. System fit matters.
So they couldn’t win a game with their backup, who is a very good backup
Sure... the Pats with the same exact QB went from 6th in scoring in 2021 to 25th in 2022, near dead last in offensive penalties in 2021 to top of the league in 2022... but coaching played no part in that. You're delusional.
It definitely did, not sure what you’re talking about
You said Stafford played well in the Super Bowl. Stop moving the goalposts.
I said in their Super Bowl year. You must’ve missed that.
The Ram's defense allowed 18 PPG and forced the third most turnovers in the playoffs, they didn't teleport there either. The Super Bowl was a modern version of a defensive battle. The Rams defense sacked Joe Burrow 7 times. It wasn't a magic QB, it was the defense... the better QB lost... again.
Stafford threw 50 touchdowns in 2021. Glad you’re pinpointing 1 game though
Josh Allen has how many Super Bowl victories? The goal posts only seem to matter when you're trying to make a point.
What goalposts? The patriots can’t beat the bills anymore, why do you think that is? Sean McDermott?
QB's aren't magic, you want great, you can win with good.
If that makes you feel better; more power to you
The Chiefs and Eagles were great teams in 2022, attributing it entirely to one player is reductionist fanboy garbage.
I didn’t attribute anything to 1 player. But the most credit and influence should go to the 2 MVP candidates. The chiefs were a great offense and a mediocre defense though, allowed 25 Ppg in the playoffs. Not very good