Man ... you guys are killing me. Just because you guys debated back and forth and were upset that there was a lot of optimism about Jones, Belichick, and the direction of the team a couple of years ago, I don't see the value in taking a victory lap. I mean, and I've said it a few times, we all lose. All of us now have to watch the same thing, and none of us had any control over what was going on throughout, regardless of our opinions of how we though it would play out.
It sucks, and there's nothing we can do to change it.
I get it. The people who claim they knew it all along are now seeing the errors over the offseason - which quite a few of us had concerns about, but were hoping it wouldn't be
this bad - come to fruition. It's been a blast, hasn't it?
Yes, Brady Left
We all saw Cam Newton's season (which started off well, but also imploded, albeit not this badly), a playoff run, last year's hot mess, and now this implosion.
We know Bill can coach. But we know that clearly, in the last few years going back to 2019 (we can debate others, but let's skip that for this exercise) roster-building has been his Achilles heel.
Brady won a title in Tampa and silenced all the doubters about him vs Manning vs Mahomes vs Rodgers vs whoever. I'd be willing to bet if he stayed and didn't get another ring, even with six, people would still question him. Fortunately, it didn't happen. Take the victory and be happy with it, because I'm also glad it ultimately played out that way.
So ... now what?
Belichick's probably done, and we're about to see an era come to an end. That whole "be careful what you wish for" thing isn't always that great. I recall the tenor back in 1997 when people said "good riddance" to Parcells after the nonsense he pulled that postseason having back-channel discussions with the Jets. Pete Carroll is looked back on much differently now here than when he was fired in 1999. Time does that.
But anyone hoping the next person is going to be a breath of fresh air may find it may actually take a couple of coaching cycles - and years of our lives - before that happens. And the first time they happen to get anywhere and a bad decision is made in a key moment, I'm guessing people will start to reflect positively with Belichick.
I'm not saying anything more than we can talk all day about Brady being the GOAT, but Brady didn't play defense, and he didn't put the game plans together that kept things close and gave both him and the offense a chance at the end. I love the guy, but he never made our lives easy and blew a single team out in any of those six Super Bowls.
Raise your hand if you wish we could not have been stressed out in the final moments of any of those. How amazing would that have been? Would have been great to just kick back - just once - and watch them run it up.
Wait until January ...
And I feel like this January, like it does each and every year, is going to reveal how important coaching is, especially because every postseason, a good quarterback also goes down thanks to that. It even happened to Brady, unfortunately. Bowles just is who he is.
Belichick certainly doesn't have a clean sweep in this category because I'll personally never let the Malcolm Butler decision go. Ever. But I don't want to talk about that in this thread.
Lastly,
@patfanken is one of the best people we've ever had on here. So, mocking him is absolutely unnecessary. You're bashing him over things he said over the course of a handful of seasons. He's been here for 20+ years, has played and coached the game, and will forget more than most of us know. And he's been far more right than he's ever been wrong.
At the end of the day, who cares? I'm cool if I'm wrong, just like I feel like most of us and you guys are. Just because someone gives me a hard time doesn't mean I'm going to throw it back in anyone's face, and I'm referring to all the other posts in this thread. It can all change in a second...it is what it is.
Nothing good is going to come from it, other than personal satisfaction. Aside from that, I don't see the benefit.
You guys are all better than this. Let's let it go and move on.