OPINION: Brady vs Rodgers - Brady Should Have Had the Edge in the Rankings

[RobertWeathers]

Rodgers is a playoff choke artist.

Brady needs a crack at this guy in the SB to shut everyone up for good.

It's a tough argument. Both are incredible talents.

As a famous coach once said, "You judge a QB by the number of fur pelts on the wall and if you want them captaining your pirate ship and crew."

Both Brady and Rodgers have had great playoff games. Both have had bad playoff games.

The only way I know how to decide which QB is better is the "one game scenario" and for me, the guy with more fur pelts wins every time.

 

[FreeTedWilliams]

Rodgers couldn't hold a 16 point playoff lead, Brady overcame 3 different 10+ point deficits in the playoffs including a 14 point 4th quarter against the same defense.

Rodgers was up 16-7 with 2:10 left and lost!!!

Now that the Peyton versus Brady debate is dead, the media must think up another player who is "better" than Brady.

Think about this fact, Brady has started 6 Superbowls, and in each and everyone, he has lead his team to a go ahead score in the last 3 minutes of every one of them.

the only one you can compare Brady to is Montana and Brady is pulling ahead in that debate too.