Bill is one of the greatest head coaches in NFL history, he's up there with George Halas and Don Shula. Hes not just a Super Bowl champion, he is a 6 time Super Bowl champion. With that being said, I think its fair to say he does have his faults and right now they're coming back to bite us especially on the offensive side of the ball.
1. Hiring Matt Patricia, his friend as a de facto offensive coordinator was a horrible move, he knows it at this point and I knew this was going to happen when it was announced. He was a good defensive coordinator for us but having him coach the offense is a horrible idea. The play calls are stale, receivers aren't getting open, there's bad situational awareness with the ball, players are making mistakes, not running the right routes etc.
2. He has not been good at building up skill positions on offense. With the exception of the 2009-2010 drafts when we got Gronk and Edelman. The N'Keal Harry experiment didn't work out, Jonnu Smith and Hunter Henry are decent but they aren't the big playmakers we thought they would be. Other teams in our division have had these big trades and free agent signings such as the dolphins drafting Jaylen Waddle and making the trade for Tyreek Hill, those are franchise altering moves. The Bills drafted guys like Gabriel Davis, Matt Milano, Josh Allen, tredavious white and also signed Stefan Diggs and Von Miller. With that being said, Right now Defensive coordinators aren't up late at night wondering who they are going to stop on offense, we haven't had that since the Gronk days and This problem really started to show in Brady's last year. Plain and simple We can't hang with the top teams in the AFC with what we have on offense. With the defense being as good as it is, this may allow us to beat some of the average teams in the league or the bad teams but when you go up against a team like Buffalo, Kansas City or Cincinnati. Not having those dynamic playmakers to put up points even with a good defense isnt good enough.
3. So I hate to sound like the glass half empty guy but if we keep going with the approach, we're going to be stuck like this in mediocrity for the next few years. Being passive on acquiring talented players on offense is a losing strategy in today's NFL. I don't think Mac is a bad quarterback, I think hes got alot of potential but having Matt Patricia as the guy who's tasked with developing him isnt gonna cut it. I am all for going out and having Bill O'Brien return as OC. He was the actual OC here before and has experience with developing quarterbacks. I think were going to have to draft some guys on the offensive line and seriously think about making a dynamic trade for a weapon on offense for Mac. There's definitely changes that need to be made or else we are going to continue to play second fiddle to the Bills for the foreseeable future. Maybe some people might disagree with me but thats how I see it.