Uptown
Hall of Fame Poster
- Joined
- Aug 26, 2016
- Messages
- 24,472
- Reaction score
- 51,135
Registered Members experience this forum ad and noise-free.
CLICK HERE to Register for a free account and login for a smoother ad-free experience. It's easy, and only takes a few moments.Yeah time will tell,I don't know how to feel about this. I don't know how big a hand he had in GB. But from 18-19 he was the assistant GM in Cleveland. His drafting in 18 was really good in 19 it wiffed, but how much say did he have for sure?
Since then you can't really judge him that well. The thing is finding talent is such a unique skill and there is no way to be sure about how good someone may be at it just because they can manage other things well and make the trains run on time.
Could be taken that way or that they worked in unison and reported up to Kraft who made all decisions.Kraft needs to stop talking. This is pretty much an open admission that they gave Wolf control of the draft, which is the Rooney Rule violation.
I don’t see how it is a violation of the Rooney rule. Last time I checked there is nothing in the rule that says that the draft must be handle by the general manager and not by the director of scouting.Kraft needs to stop talking. This is pretty much an open admission that they gave Wolf control of the draft, which is the Rooney Rule violation.
For the slow people in the room, could some clarify if that title is now what used to be called the GM (or was it always?)
I think that’s their argument. The problem is that saying they wanted to see how Wolf handled it can also be taken by NFL as they gave Wolf control but not the title. The control is what has to be interviewed for, not the title. And while the Pats can make any argument they want, giving the NFL ammunition to penalize the Pats very rarely turns out well for the Pats.Could be taken that way or that they worked in unison and reported up to Kraft who made all decisions.
They can say that, but why did Wolf say before the draft that he had final say over the draft?It appears Kraft doesn’t want to give so much power to one person so it’s Wolf, Mayo and staff in concert with all decisions going thru Kraft prior?
Vs Bill having full autonomy.
This could impact the speed we can trade for or deal a player.
Wolf having say on the 53 I’m sure Mayo would fight for a guy he believes should be there.
The title isn’t what matters for the Rooney Rule. It’s for any senior executive with say over personnel. Saying or implying that they gave that control to Wolf in a probationary capacity is the same as saying they gave Wolf control without interviewing other candidates. That’s the violation.I don’t see how it is a violation of the Rooney rule. Last time I checked there is nothing in the rule that says that the draft must be handle by the general manager and not by the director of scouting.
Some teams do that and others don’t. Pros and cons either way. It’s good to let the coach pick the final 53 but he might prioritize short term winning and cut a player who needs another year of development, which then makes it look like the personnel dept made a “bad” pick or signing. So the overall long term vision for the roster that the personnel dept wants to build can be maintained. However at the same time the coach has some level of immunity because he can say “I would’ve kept player X, if we kept him then we would’ve possibly won more games but it’s not up to me”. He doesn’t control what ingredients he gets but he’s in charge of cooking the dish etc. Depends on how convincing that situation is.Weird he has control of the 53, isn’t that usually the HC?
So according to the league the Pats are compliant because there was no such position until Wolf was hired?
| 25 | 2K |
| 204 | 8K |
| 65 | 3K |
| 1 | 531 |
From our archive - this week all-time:
April 20 - May 5 (Through 26yrs)











