- Joined
- Sep 7, 2006
- Messages
- 73,412
- Reaction score
- 116,112
Yea no need to nit pick on your order. Malcolm, Gonzo, A$ante, and JC all made All-Pro at one time or another..... FWIW I had Logan at #6 but felt JJ had the better career here.This is going to shock people with this list. My top 5 drafted/undrafted CB's in the BB era:
1. JC Jackson. He lead the league in INT's and pass breakups since his time as a Patriot. Made the Pro Bowl and was 2nd team All Pro in 2021. He was a very good CB before he opted for surgery right before the season he signed with LA. That was a big mistake for him waiting so long. Then the Chargers used him as the scapegoat when the team doctors botched his rehab clearing him way too early. I didn't need to be a Doctor to figure that out when Mac Jones took just as long on sprain as JC later did surgery. He could barely run and was never the same.
2. Asante Samuel. He was good as a reserve in 2003 and 2004, but he was horrible as a starter in 2005 regularly getting torched by the better WR's in the league. 2006 and 2007 were his breakout years. He'd easily be #1 and have the keys to the city if weren't for a few plays late in SB42.
3. Christian Gonzalez. Made 2nd team All Pro in his first full season as a starter. He will probably end up #1 soon.
4. Malcolm Butler. He was really solid as Revis' replacement in 2015. His biggest issue was that he couldn't make plays. He had the Ellis Hobbs syndrome where he'd be in position to break up a pass or even get an INT, but the opposing player would outmuscle him for the ball.
5. Logan Ryan. Very solid #2 CB. His best moment was getting flagged for the crotch crab celebration on an INT return for a TD.
Honorable mention: Jonathan Jones.
I agree on Gonzo climbing the rankings. At this rate he could be the best in the league.












